PDA

View Full Version : 12" PowerBook Review - PC switcher's perspective


sdilley14
02-07-2006, 07:36 AM
First off, I want to state that I am a life long PC user, my first PC being a 133mhz P1 w/28k modem and Windows 95. I've been through every generation of Windows since then and have owned 10 or 12 different PCs since then - my last two PCs being an Inspiron6000D loaded to the max from Dell, and a Gateway 2.2GHZ Athlon, 512, 160, DVDRW. So as you can imagine, I was pretty skeptical about making the switch to Mac.

After endless research, comparing, checking message boards, and tough deliberation, I decided to make the jump and purchase a PowerBook. I keep all of my PCs running in top shape, never having any pop-ups, viruses, etc. But the effort that it takes to keep a PC running well feels like an uphill battle that you literally have to take on every single day. I finally got fed up with it. It got to the point where I actually dreaded turning on the PC because I knew I'd have to do a spyware scan, virus scan, take items off the start-up list, and even after doing all of that, certain programs were still painfully slow. I finally had enough and wanted to explore other avenues.

I decided to go with the 12" PowerBook. OSX 10.4.4, 1.5ghz G4, 768 MB (supposed to be 512 but Apple shipped to me with 768? no complaints!) 80GB, SuperDrive, BT, AE.

Initial reaction - I don't even need to say it as everyone is already well aware. The form factor of the machine is miles ahead of any other laptop...period. The thing is beautiful. There is definately a unique feel to handling a PowerBook. The build is sleek and solid and the keyboard is great, giving no flex whatsoever.

Set up was a breeze. It took no more than 15 minutes to go from start up to being on the net. The AE card instantly recognized my wireless signal - no additional set up required. Literally, a 5th grader could set this thing up.

I gave it two weeks so I could write a fair review, as I know most PCs are pretty quick right out of the box but slow down considerably after loading 40 gigs of music, videos, programs, and other files onto them, then surfing the web and downloading more things. After two weeks and loading 40 gigs of files onto this off of my external hard drive, it's still running like a champ...faster and EASILY more stable than ANY PC I've owned...period! I cannot say enough about the stability of OSX. Two weeks of solid, consistent use and still haven't had to reboot for any reason other than going to bed at night and letting the computer get a nap. Also haven't had to force quit any programs. I'm constantly running Safari, iTunes, LimeWire, BitTorrent, and Photoshop, and there hasn't been any memory shortage, lag in any of the programs, or any need to force quit or restart anything. I've found the stability of this to be remarkable thus far.

My primary concern about switching to Mac was the same misconception most PC users have who are afraid to embrace a good change to their PC lives..."will I be able to use "x" program on a Mac?" "There aren't as many programs for a Mac." I've found that I can do everything I could on a PC - video editing, music, photo editing, word processing, downloading, surfing, everything - even better than before. I find myself constantly finding new programs, new widgets, new tweaks...new everything. I'm using programs and doing things on this PowerBook that I never even thought of doing on any PC. So far it has been very inducive to creative thought and change. :)

Battery life is excellent (3 hours atleast, multi-tasking, lcd turned down 2 or 3 notches, running iTunes). Keyboard, as I mentioned before is great - solid build with no flex. The misconception that the laptop is too hot is just that...a misconception. I've owned three PC laptops and this is absolutely no hotter than previous laptops I've owned. AirPort reception is also great, although I'm never more than 20-30 feet away from the router. Native screen resolution is 1024x768, so it won't make your jaw drop, but you also won't have to squint your eyes like some people say they do. This thing is also virtually silent, with the fan only coming on when you're doing heavy multi-tasking, and even then it is only a quiet whirring sound that you hear. The accompanying software that comes with OSX is also a great compliment to an amazing OS. I personally love Safari; the seamlesss integration it has with OSX is a pleasant change from IE.

I could go on for hours about Quartz graphics, Spotlight Search, Dashboard, widgets, expose`, and all of the other small but intuitive features that are integrated with OSX. Bottom line...this thing is AWESOME. It's pretty amazing, the improvements that have been made since OS9 (last time I really used a Mac). OSX is truly a breath of fresh air. The upkeeping it requires to run smoothly is microscopic compared to PCs. Stability, productivity, speed, function, style, and features - I absolutely could not be happier with my purchase and I have no intentions of switching back to PC. My suggesstion - if anyone is curious, fed up with Windows, or is bored and just wants to give it a try, I strongly suggest giving OSX a shot.

Mix_D
02-07-2006, 12:59 PM
I'm thinking to purchase a 12" powerbook with 1.25gb. I'm switching to OSX mainly because of Videos, Musics and Photos. My PC is running slow after performing editing for vmps. I was hopping that OSX can run smoother and faster.

Did anyone try to edit and burn a video (from camcorder or video file)with OSX? How long does it take and how is the quality for an hour footage? I know music and photo editing wouldn't be a disappointment with OSX (well, according to my research on reviews and comments) but video is my main concern.

triadone
02-07-2006, 04:44 PM
nice review. :) you've discovered what many of us have as well, congrats! i can't remember offhand if the firewall is enabled by default. in any case the greatest measures u need to take w/ a mac are to perhaps turn on the firewall and activate it's stealth mode (depending on what apps u use. u may need this off for remote management) and you're all set. :)

triadone
02-07-2006, 05:05 PM
I'm thinking to purchase a 12" powerbook with 1.25gb. I'm switching to OSX mainly because of Videos, Musics and Photos. My PC is running slow after performing editing for vmps. I was hopping that OSX can run smoother and faster.

Did anyone try to edit and burn a video (from camcorder or video file)with OSX? How long does it take and how is the quality for an hour footage? I know music and photo editing wouldn't be a disappointment with OSX (well, according to my research on reviews and comments) but video is my main concern.

i guess it depends on your source. if it's from a camcorder and u have the firewire plugged in it will basically give u the quality of the camcorder. it will basically take as long as it takes for the playback of the tape. recording is in raw uncompressed DV format so the quality is basically as good as u can get.

if u have a hard drive based camcorder like the JVC everio, then it's a matter of how long it will take to convert the mpeg2 file to DV for editing. iMovie converts all video to DV for editing as the lack of compression allows the filters and such to be rendered asap. for me, most scene transitions take 3-10 seconds to render based on the settings. i won't lie however, conversion to DV takes a while, but then again it's a painstaking task on any system. often, when really working in a pinch i'll use quicktime in windows to convert to DV and then drop it onto my iBook over the network. the athlon 3200+ is a bit faster at the DV conversion than my 1.2Ghz G4, but again it's a wait on either system.

authoring time really depends on the type of video you're exporting to. in authoring a recent 120 minute DVD i can't give specifics, but i can say that when i started the encode b4 bed it was done by morning. not bad, considering a high quality 2-pass Divx rip on my desktop can easily take longer than that.

Mix_D
02-08-2006, 12:37 AM
Awesome! Thank you for your explanation triadone

triadone
02-08-2006, 01:42 AM
no problem :D

HenryS
02-08-2006, 09:17 AM
Thank you for the review. I am in a similar place - trying to decide between an Asus Z33ae and the Powerbook. I've resolved my compatibility issues with my Microsoft based co-workers. The only thing holding me back from purchasing the powerbook is Microsoft Office for Mac appears to be the only productivity suite. I need a spreadsheet and database with Office compatibility for work and do a lot of word processing at home. Reviews of Office for Mac complain about bugs and Word keyboard delays. It's hard to get my head around - leaving windows based machines for Mac stability then loading another buggy Microsoft product for work. Any experience with Office for Mac?

Thanks again,
Henry

triadone
02-08-2006, 02:29 PM
works fine on my end, i can only imagine it's more responsive @ 1.5Ghz+. OpenOffice/NeoOffice is another option too, though personally i haven't used any of the spreadsheet options w/ them. The KB issue isn't Mac specific. the only time i notice it is if the system is under load when trying to do some serious multitasking (video editing + photoshop + saturated network + multiple browser windows open + etc). having just upgraded my desktop to 1.25GB of RAM i'm finally getting the responsiveness in multitasking that i've had on my iBook w/ 768MB all along. what i will say re: windows on a single core processor and moderate RAM, is that u don't just wait for the KB or letters to show up in Word, u wait for the whole damn OS to switch panes to what u'd like to be working on. that said, in windows, when in word and while doing heavy loads w/ other apps in the background, u get the KB delay as well and IMO it's much worse in windows. on any system windows or OS X i'd recommend getting 1GB of RAM for business work. no need in letting your specs slow down your productivity. :)

nhclubowner
03-12-2006, 09:31 PM
Would be nice if I knew how.

Dave
12" Powerbook

triadone
03-13-2006, 01:16 AM
download VLC, best media player i've used. much more efficient than quicktime. quicktime itself should play avi files, so i'm guessing u r trying to play divx files or something of the like. :)

drknsurfur
03-27-2006, 02:16 PM
Ok guys i have just bought an apple powerbook off one of my friends because i have never owned an apple and i wanted to get away from dell because i have had bad times with them. i was wondering if this could handle any type of games like Counterstrike or stuff like that.


Apple 12 inch powerbook
1.3 ghz
NVIDIA GeForce FX Go5200 64mb
60gig 5400

??

EvilSquid
03-27-2006, 06:28 PM
Apples don't do counterstrike or most games for that matter

Kakaze
03-27-2006, 06:34 PM
Many games are available for Macs, unfortunately Counterstrike isn't one of them.

drknsurfur
03-27-2006, 07:20 PM
what about WOW will it be alright with that?? i know they make it for a mac

Kakaze
03-27-2006, 10:47 PM
WoW should run well

drknsurfur
03-28-2006, 12:20 AM
also if it is too slow for WoW or other things are they easily upgradable sorry for the dumb questions but again this is my first mac and ive always been a sceptic so never even looked up on them

Kakaze
03-28-2006, 03:08 AM
Memory and harddrive are about the only things you can upgrade.