NotebookForums.com › Reviews & Benchmarks › Notebooks › Apple iPAD › Reviews › marker01's Review

Apple iPAD

A Review On: Apple iPAD

Apple iPAD

Rated # 29 in Notebooks
See all 2 reviews
Review Details:
Build Quality
Screen Quality
Battery Life
Aesthetics
Port Placement
Performance
marker01
Posted · 1 View · 9 Comments
As a test, I will attempt to write this entire review only on the iPad.

When the iPad was announced, i was not impressed. As a self noted computer enthusiast, I knew the industry has already given tablet PC's a try and were not very successful. However, the market has changed, and the iPad does have a standing chance as competition in the netbook market.

Unfortunately, I no longer own a netbook, I replaced its functionality with the Dell XPS 1340, a 13" notebook with a decent GPU. I miss the netbook; having a computer always on (standby at worst) just lying around the house was very beneficial.

I picked up the iPad with this exact purpose in mind, I wanted something lying around the common area of the house that didn't take up space, was always on, and didn't require me to even think about the battery power remaining.

This comes in handy almost every day; the wife says she's running to taco bell and wants my order, I can quickly pull up Tacobell.com. The kids ask what year George Washington died, i can answer in seconds.

Tech Specs:
1024x768 9.7" LED Multi-Touch Screen
1Ghz A4 CPU
64GB Flash Drive
Wi-Fi (802.11 a/b/g/n)
Bluetooth 2.1 + EDR


Size & Weight:
Apple got the size right! The iPad is not to large, and not to small.
Weight on the other hand needed more attention; 1.5lbs is heavier then you might think. A 30 year old man will have no problems "one handing" the iPad, but I don't think Grandma would like it.

iPad compared with the Dell XPS 1340 (13") and the original Alienware m15x (15")





Screen:
Truly amazing. The 1024x768 LED delivers great HD quality video and at 9.7" a reasonably sized family can all enjoy a movie watching the same screen. Yesterday I purchased the new Alice in Wonderland from iTunes in HD. My wife, kid, and I all enjoyed it on the iPad. We did have the iPad pretty close to where we were sitting.

3D Performance:
It's difficult to benchmark an iPad, the only real comparisons you see is to the iPhone. That said, there is a 3D benchmark utility on the Apple app store called 3D Bench. Originally designed for the iPhone, this app runs a quick 3D benchmark similar to 3D Mark.
My average FPS was 57.8. To compare, I asked my brother to run this on his 3G iPhone (the second one) and his score was 19.2 FPS.

Some users have posted their results, which look similar to mine. http://forums.toucharcade.com/showthread.php?t=52041.
I know this is not as comprehensive as a 3D Mark benchmark and comparison, but it is the best i could find.

3D Gaming works great!
iPad gaming is like a closed community; you're not getting WoW or MW2, but iPad does have MMORPGs, FPS's, and retro remakes.

Pocket Legends (MMORPG)


Brothers in Arms 2


Final Fantasy



Keyboard:
The onscreen keyboard works great in both landscape and portrait mode. This is a multi touch screen, so holding shift while you type is possible. The onscreen keyboard "smartly" changes the default keys depending on the input type. For example, when you starting typing a web address in Safari, it removes the spacebar (because you cant use spaces in a URL) and adds a ".com" button for convenience. This is a great idea, but it's not as "smart" as I would like. It wont know the expected text type for most internet sites, so it is constantly moving keys like the @ symbol and _ all over the pace; don't put a _ in your username if possible, i keep digging to find the key.






You can lay the iPad on a flat surface and start typing with both hands and all 10 fingers. The reality is you'll likely need to hold the iPad and one finger peck, or single had typing works best.
In the event you want to do some serious typing, like writing a NBF review, you'll want the Apple bluetooth keyboard! Adding a keyboard and mouse (mouse doesn't work by default, I'll get into that) to the iPad and you have all the internet surfing capabilities of any netbook, notebook, or even desktop PC.




Unfortunately, the iPad does not support any mouse! However, if you chose to jailbreak your system there is a workaround. BTStack Mouse by BigBoss is the application you are looking for. Because of the way it works (must disable the default bluetooth option), you'll also need BTstack Keyboard to have both mouse and keyboard functionality. It's convoluted to setup, and a bit flakey, but I know nothing about Mac's and figured it out.


Bluetooth:
Very important for me, I have 5 BT devices lined up for the iPad.


Motorola HT820 BT headphones
Motorola T505 (Hands free BT car speaker with FM broadcaster)
Nokia MD-7W (Portable BT Stereo Speakers)
Apple Wireless Keyboard
Microsoft Bluetooth Notebook Mouse


Aside from the mouse issue described earlier, everything paired perfectly.


I want to take a moment and explain how impressed I am with the iPad's bluetooth module.
I have run these Motorola headphones and Nokia speakers through three laptops and two smart phones and none of them worked well. Each had their unique quirks but the main problem was BT audio/video lag. Listening to music was never a problem, but watching TV or a movie with BT speakers was unacceptable; its like watching an American made Japanese movie, where the actor's lips do not match the sound...

The iPad preformed flawlessly with all bluetooth devices I could throw at it. The BT headphones and speakers were dead on accurate, making TV/Movie viewing enjoyable again! I even took the Motorola T505 (Hands free BT car speaker with FM broadcaster) into the house and tuned the FM radio on my Bose which allowed me to play a movie in 5.1 digital surround sound via bluetooth with no audio/video latency!!


Productivity:
Some may be interested to hear about the Cisco VPN client included with the iPad. It can be found under Settings > General > Network > VPN. When creating a connection, chose IPSec (third option) for the Cisco VPN client.



I had no problems connecting to the VPN concentrator. I found a free RDP app called Remote Desktop Lite in the app store, I was able to remote to my work PC.

Yay, I can RDP to work from my iPad! Wait a minute...


Conclusion:
I'll take it!


I did actually complete this entire review on the iPad, using the wireless keyboard and Pages as a word processor. I did have to upload the pictures from a PC.

9 Comments

Wow! I am totally impressed. Mucho thanks for the submission of this review REP!

cheers ...
Pics uploaded from PC?
Intro
So here I go - I'm writing a review for the iPad. Why? I've been thinking a lot about mobile development recently for a passion project of mine as well as some new features for NBF. Got a friend with a pad and the owner of Mach 3 composites has offered to ship out some of his carbon fiber cases for review. So hey! why not?

I will start by saying that I've never been much of an Apple guy. Most of my background lies within PC-based platforms, namely Windows. However given my experiences as a dev/sysadmin for NBF and other projects, I've obtained knowlege of linux systems. I see most of Apple's products as proprietary Linux distributions with pre-packaged hardware. In fact, everything Apple has to offer seems to be sold as a unit and the iPad is no different.

I wanted to follow Notebookforum's review template and line up some of the features of the pad, then bash out what I really think. There's a TON of iPad reviews so if your looking for a super duper resourceful review, go elsewhere

Our very own QHN has translated some content which exposes iPad internals:
http://www.notebookforums.com/thread232432.html
and Marker01 has a steller review.
http://www.notebookforums.com/thread232978.html


Specs:
Specs are mostly standardized across iPads accept for the hard drive sizes. I played with the 16GB version.
  • 1024-by-768-pixel resolution at 132 pixels per inch (ppi)
  • 1GHz Apple A4 custom-designed, high-performance, low-power system-on-a-chip
  • 16GB, 32GB, or 64GB flash drive
  • Accelerometer
  • Ambient light sensor
  • Built-in 25-watt-hour rechargeable lithium-polymer battery
  • Fingerprint-resistant oleophobic coating
  • 256mb (accessible memory)
  • Built-in speaker
  • mic
You can view the original specs here:
http://www.apple.com/ipad/specs/

What's in the Box:
I had the good fortune of borrowing this unit from one of our mods who is big on custom systems and new technology so I didn't get the official UPS delivery. If you want to know what's in the box go

Design/Screen
My first impressions blew me out of the water. As with most of Apples products design of the iPad is sleek. It's important to note that the iPad attempts change up user computing experience largely. You control everything via the touch screen. No mouse, no keyboard, no USB ports, no external monitors. The screen is terrific and the colors were so intense and so crisp, I felt I could take off my glasses. You don't have to worry about glare and any touch smudges are invisible simply because of the bright ass screen. Also the viewing angle is near perfect due to the LCD's in-place-switching.
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/...ide,116-3.html

Keyboard
The Keyboard pops up as you need it. Typing is pretty easy but does not stand as a viable substiute for a standard keyboard. At least not for long period typing. So, if you have to type for an extended amount of time, get the keyboard dock or hook up a bluetooth keyboard as Marker01 mentioned.

Speakers
Speakers are built in and on the side. They sound pretty good, decent volume (for a built in) and you can't crank the volume up high enough for sound to crackle which is good.

Webcam Pictures
Unfortunately there is no webcam. There's a lot of complaints about this. You'd think since the iPad is a cross between a Netbook and mobile phone (both of which have cameras), it should include one.

Benchmarks
The only benchmarks I could run on this machine was Peacekeeper which is hapens to be a great benchmark for web experience. The iPad didn't do so hot. 380 Points.
http://www.notebookforums.com/attach...1&d=1277041737

Size and Weight
My impressions were that it was very thin and heavier then you'd expect looking at it; and still lightweight. I'd say you couldn't read lying on your back, hands above your head for too long before your arms got tired. But I've been watching my wife play HD Pinball on it longer then I'd expect. She later started playing racing games and looked as if she was working out. Compared to a book, it's not cumbersome and has the bonus of custom font size/lettering and screen brightness.

Heat and Noise
The iPad doesn't get hot. Especially compared to most of the laptops I've played with.

Battery Life
The iPad gets an insane amount of battery life. Which leads me to what I wanted to talk about.

Developing
As I said earlier, I was curious about development. I've been coding over a decade and I know lots of languages well. I have a tendency to hand-code a lot of what I do and I like things my way. As a single developer, I'm all about cross-platform development - I don't want to have to code the same thing twice and is why I like web dev.

For the iPad (and iPhone 4). It's all about apps. Apps Apps Apps! Apps are written in Apple's objective-c (which is just extended c), that's good; it's fast and efficient. It's fast because c compiles into machine code/native code which the processor rocks out. But what stinks (besides having to buy the SDK) is apps aren't cross platform. The only thing that exists right now that delivers a decent cross-platform solution is Flash (Java is less supported). The iPad is flashless.

Flash is compiled into bytecode which has to be interpreted into machine code. This interpreter which is part of the runtime, comes at cost which Apple has decided isn't good enough to ship with. It's not as fast, is less memory efficient and consumes more battery life. But the way I see it, it's not like the iPad doesn't have great resource management and they could have easily made a sacrifice. I'd take the trade-off. I don't believe flash affects performance as much as stated anyway. Not to mention there's a ton of sites that absolutely require flash as a delivery medium. Who wants to spend 10 hours surfing an incomplete web?

Anyway the proposed "cross-platform" solution is HTML5. And there's a TON of information available on it. At one point I was confused because I had seen a demo of HTML5 running Quake II in the browser. That's not the case. It's actually google's nativeclient at work:
http://code.google.com/p/nativeclient/
but they do have intent to incorporate a sand-boxed native code object in HTML5 and they want it standardized.

HTML5 really just extends and refines it's predecessor and uses the same languages (JavaScript/HTML/CSS). The main benefit is the increase in JavaScript speeds by allowing users explicitly create worker threads. ooo multi-threading.
HTML5 of course is packaged as the browser - no runtimes - nice and portable. What else is HTML5 makes it easy for people to embed audio and video, and it will support a variety of codecs in the browser. Google already has an HTML5 version of youtube (which doesn't work very well).

Ok so, I get it. HTML5 is the bomb... However, it's brand new. Specifications are still being drawn and it's simply not a solution yet. Especially when your talking in regard to raw sound, microphone access, or web reach. For me personally, I fully plan to get my geek on with HTML5. But Flash at it's current state gives me real time ability to develop app-like interfaces and if it weren't for Apple it would be cross-platform.

I also wonder whether battery life will decrease when some serious HTML5 websites are created. Seems to me since JavaScript is interpreted at runtime (more so then Flash) it would be harder on the CPU and Apple might run into similar problems with HTML5 as the ones they encountered with Flash and battery life. To test this, I tried open all 9 tabs in Safari and point them to the sunspider javascript benchmark. You can't say. I noticed Safari only ran the JavaScript of the tab in focus and stopped execution of the others. Stopping execution doesn't seem to be a good idea considering HTML5's specifications for Socket and Worker threads. Food for thought.

Case
Mach 3 Composites is shipping me their case and I'm looking forward to reviewing it. From what I've seen their cases are the best on the market. So I will try to get some decent pictures and update this thread when it arrives.

UPDATE
You can read the review here:
http://www.notebookforums.com/thread233754.html

I just wanted to wrap up by saying that the iPad is pretty slick gadget.. Everything is lighting fast which is amazing considering the processor in it - near perfect. I applaud this system. Completely intuitive. I just wish it was a little bit more of a computer with things like shell access and runtimes. Then I'd buy it.
Whoa Shaun. Nice write up. How do I index this?
Nice review and video enjoyed it thanks but all i can say is notion ink adam. if its what is promised at the price, then as usual the alternative to the mac is slightly cheaper with better technology but this would be consistant.
Mine has been a total disaster. I will hopefully get it replaced Wednesday. It locks up
of no reason without input from me. I bought it for internet and email use. Mine is not usable for that
at the moment. A defective product. I pay a ton for 3G with unlimited access.
I bought it before the deadline with AT&T.

Great review and one of the reasons, I got it.
Do you feel good with the iPad? Friends told me that I should still wait for a while when iPad gots verything update and completed documents. Is that true?
It is the coolest looking, most protective case you can get for your ipad.

Great review
Quote:
Originally Posted by Shaun
case is not waterproof


good review, Shaun!
NotebookForums.com › Reviews & Benchmarks › Notebooks › Apple iPAD › Reviews › marker01's Review