New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Extigy + MP3 = ?

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
My quest for a good audio device for my 8890 continues. It starts on this post if you want a little background.

http://sagerforums.com/showthread.php?t=9659

I returned the Phillips Aurilium I purchased choosing to stick with the Extigy. With further use and tests I have hit a stumbleing block. The Extigy sucks when playing music. There is no other way to put it. Here is what is happening.

If you plug front and rear speakers into any other sound card and play MP3's or CD's and such you get stereo sound piped through all your speakers. With the Extigy you get stereo in the front speakers and ONLY the front speakers. Why? Got me. To make it so you can hear music in the rest of your speakers, like the rear speakers you have plugged into the Extigy that work with everyting else you have plugged them into, you push a button on the front of the Extigy that turns on CMSS (Creative MultiSpeaker Suround). Ok, fine, now you have stereo playing on your speakers. Great, those rear speakers are now playing music like they should. There is only one problem... the sound sucks.

CMSS "upmixes" (Creative's word) the stereo signal so that it can be played on more then the front speakers. When the Extigy "upmixes' the siginal it kills it. Most of the bass is lost, the vocals fade away and sometimes are lost in the twangy sound that use to be music that is now spewing out of the speakers. In addition for some reason I have found that the CMSS adds an echo to everything. So in the end with a $300+ speaker system and a $150 external sound card I can chose to have decent sound from 2 speakers or crappy sound that is only better then the internal speakers on my 8890.

Whew, sorry, venting there.

In any case, has anyone experianced something similar using the Extigy and a 4.1 speaker system (Klisph Promedia THX 4.1 system)? Anyone happen to have a suggestion as to how to improve the situation? I might just have to return the Extigy... mabe the Aruilium I returned early this week will still be sitting on the shelf and I can get it again.

BAH!!!
post #2 of 5
wow, sorry to hear about the sucking.... It may perhaps be that the only solution is to go all digital or subscribe to a set of speakers from creative. I hate to say it but while creative has a done a lot for sound systems on computers they still enjoy making stuff just proprietary enought to make me want to murder someone. Being a big fan of high quality audio though, especially for music i have to say that I have always piped my music through my stero reciever. I use digital coax to hook the comp to the stereo (fiber optic is too epensive for any real distance). But as far as the audigy goes... 1st check your bit-rate on your mp3's, if its anything below 128 (i prefer 196) that may be the reason. Also see if you can manipulate the properties for the css though the creative software you have... if not... you may be mildly screwed. I know that I plan to purchase the phillips aurilium when I get back to the US, mostly because I love music... and it does that well. Also, as far as suround on games... I can live without it for the most part... its way neato, but.. I just dont get enough out of it.. I get more from a good set of headphones.
post #3 of 5
That's odd. The desktop Audigy's CMSS was great, and fully configurable.

I'd like to hear more about the Audigy NX myself.
post #4 of 5
i use the audigy2 nx myself...and it actually improved the bass response and volume. its a lot better than plugging into my 8890 directly. i use cmss and it works as expected. the only thing is that after every reboot it turns itself off. hopefully a patch would fix this in the next update.
post #5 of 5
I have a extigy and a creative 5.1 system and it sounds good to me
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Notebook Audio & Video