NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Forums › Asus Notebook Reviews › Review: Seppuku's z70va “refresh” Review
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Review: Seppuku's z70va “refresh” Review

post #1 of 28
Thread Starter 
Now understand that this is the first laptop computer I have ever owned. I have had several desktops over the years, and even built the last one from scratch myself, but never a notebook PC. So with that in mind, you’ll hopefully understand my point of view as I have nothing else to connect the z70va too.

1. The Build:
It’s quite a sleek and stylish computer. Everything about it is solid and well put together. I can’t really add anymore than what everyone else has already said about it. It looks good and is well built.

2. The Screen:
Absolutely gorgeous! Very crisp and clear with no dead pixels at all. There is a minor amount of color bleed at the bottom of the screen when it’s black (kinda like a feint white glow at the bottom), but otherwise it’s just about the best notebook screen I have ever seen!

3. Noise and Heat:
This is where the z70va shows its flaws. With both the CPU and GPU fans running at the same time (during gaming) it can be a little loud. With normal apps though (CPU fan running only) it’s pretty quiet. I can still hear the CPU fan in these instances, but only if I really pay attention to it. It’s not obtrusive at all.
The heat though is something that surprised and mildly disappointed me. Right now (just running a word proc) you can barely feel the heat coming off the fan, but if I run multiple apps or a game, it gets pretty hot. And what’s with the CPU fan blowing on my mouse hand? That’s pretty damn annoying.

4. Performance:
It’s a champ, pure and true. I was able to run BF2 in 1400x resolution with max details and there were only minor hiccups. It played the game flawlessly in 1024x768 with details at medium. I probably could have left the details at max in that resolution, but when I have them set like that at 1400x res, the machine overheated and locked up (so I had to do a shutdown to let it cool). Silent Hunter III runs extremely smooth in it’s ONLY resolution of 1024x768. Doom 3 is the real test, but I have yet to try it out on this rig. I’m sure HL2 looks stunning as well.

5. Weight and Size:
Out of the box it was slightly larger than I expected, but when compared to the size of all the other notebooks I have ever seen, I’d say it’s just slightly below moderate size. It’s much more beefy than I thought as well, but since it’s strictly a home laptop for me, the weight issue is no biggie.

Overall I’m really happy with how powerful the notebook is. It looks very clean and professional, has a nice and sturdy build, and can do pretty much anything I want it to do for the most part. The noise is acceptable, but the heat issues put me off a bit. I have not had a chance to test battery life yet, but everyone says it gets about three hours on the batt.

Out of 0% to 100%, I give the Asus z70va “refresh” a:

93.5% - Excellent notebook!
post #2 of 28
Thread Starter 
Oh, and by-the-way: Thank you to everyone here that helped me on my research for finding the notebook that was right for me!

Notebook forums RULE!
post #3 of 28
I basically come from the same back ground with you. (Build computers) never had a notebook. My gf's laptop is an old toshiba pentium 2.6 and that bitch always over heats. No matter if she is typing word or just surfing the internet. I think it is just poor lay out quality of the air flow of the laptop.

I hope asus doesn't have this same problem, especially after you said it overheated in the middle of a game.

I'm pretty much stuck on getting the z70va or the z71v. I'm not sure what is better for me:

z70va -
Pros:
looks cooler then the z71v
Bluetooth
Cons:
intergrated video 128mb ati
no sata

z71v -
Pros:
sata, 128mb card that is not intergrated, built in mic, ALS brightness mode, nvida drivers > ati, some say better audio
Cons:
Not as cool looking, Some say sparkles on the screen on white and green background.

I'm more leaning towards the z71v because of the video card and sata.
post #4 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by hywdx80
I'm more leaning towards the z71v because of the video card and sata.
Is a SATA drive generally better than a PATA drive for a laptop, or is it only when you are planning to use two of them in a RAID configuration?
post #5 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by Sangorel
Is a SATA drive generally better than a PATA drive for a laptop, or is it only when you are planning to use two of them in a RAID configuration?
Not really, you won't even notice the difference in speed because it'll bottle neck. The good thing is that it uses less power. By the way, the Z70VA's video is a lot better than the Z71V's and the screen is by far a lot better also. I don't see why anyone would pick a Z71V over the Z70VA.
post #6 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by madmike23
Not really, you won't even notice the difference in speed because it'll bottle neck. The good thing is that it uses less power. By the way, the Z70VA's video is a lot better than the Z71V's and the screen is by far a lot better also. I don't see why anyone would pick a Z71V over the Z70VA.
heat output & fan noise would be 2 reasons, or linux compatibility. The Z71v is also slightly cheaper.
post #7 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by Djembe
heat output & fan noise would be 2 reasons, or linux compatibility. The Z71v is also slightly cheaper.
Heat- not much, Fan Noise- normal for a powerful computer, and linux- Knoppix and Kubuntu worked fine for me when I was testing it out. An extra 100+ bucks is well worth it for the Z70VA. I've got a Z70V now and the Z70VA is on it's way.
post #8 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by hywdx80
Cons:
intergrated video 128mb ati
Since when did this become a con? "Integrated video" doesn't mean you're getting an "Intel Xtreme Crapola Graphics" processor, it just means the chipset is on the mobo. Really, I don't even know what to say...
post #9 of 28
The Z70va's graphics is not integrated. Far from it. In fact the X700 is slightly faster than the Go 6600 included in the Z71V.
post #10 of 28
Quote:
The Z70va's graphics is not integrated. Far from it. In fact the X700 is slightly faster than the Go 6600 included in the Z71V.
BUt doesn't that have to do more with the clock frequency, I thought in a side by side caomparison (i know it was in desktop card but so what) they scored basically the same. Furthermore I haven't really been bothered by screen issues on the z71v I actually like it a lot more then my last two notebooks (gateway m505, m675). And I thought the sata drives actleast the one's hopefully to be realeased soon are going to be faster due to the 1.5gb transfer rate.
post #11 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by chuck232
The Z70va's graphics is not integrated. Far from it. In fact the X700 is slightly faster than the Go 6600 included in the Z71V.
I think he was talking about being soldered onto the motherboard instead of being Modular like the Z71V. But still it shouldn't matter. Like what're you going to change it with?
post #12 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by madmike23
I think he was talking about being soldered onto the motherboard instead of being Modular like the Z71V. But still it shouldn't matter. Like what're you going to change it with?
There's a difference between integrated and solders. Integrated implies being built into the NB or a similar portion of the system. Being soldered onto the actual mainboard would just be a design thing.

Just trying to clear things up. I know at least I think of integration with the NB when I think of integrated video.
post #13 of 28
Yes we know. We were wondering why hywdx80 thought having integrated video was a "con" for the Z70VA. You can't really replace it with anything, so it wouldn't matter if the video was going soldered or not.
post #14 of 28
Like i said before, I really dont know much about notebooks so bare with me. I just know if a video card is intergated into a motherboard this is bad news. You can swap the video cards out if you diside to upgrade. Correct me if im wrong ?
post #15 of 28
"I just know if a video card is intergated into a motherboard this is bad news. You can swap the video cards out if you diside to upgrade. Correct me if im wrong ?"

Applies to desktop computers.
post #16 of 28
Thread Starter 
Yeah, I don't think you can swap out a notebook vid card yourself.
post #17 of 28
There is also a diference between integrated into the motherboard and integrated into the chipset...

Motherboard Integration is like soldering in the graphics card to the AGP/PCI-E bus...

Chipset integration has a potential for being a good choice... but higher costs of more powerful Graphics cards make manufacturers and system designers shy away from that option... leaving crappy, but*usually* cooler running, cheaper to manufacture and sell, video cards integrated into the chipset.
post #18 of 28
ya the x700 in the z70va does better than the 6600go of the z71v when stock

its not an integrated mobile card its a indepent gpu

if that is a big factor on ur descision of purchasing the laptop u need ot know the z70va performs generally better in games

and in terms of upgrading its unlikely ud be able to upgrade in any of them due to the variation of laptop gfx cards
post #19 of 28
Quote:
Originally Posted by NightbladeX
ya the x700 in the z70va does better than the 6600go of the z71v when stock

its not an integrated mobile card its a indepent gpu

if that is a big factor on ur descision of purchasing the laptop u need ot know the z70va performs generally better in games

and in terms of upgrading its unlikely ud be able to upgrade in any of them due to the variation of laptop gfx cards
This seems to be coming up repeatedly... can someone confirm that if you have two notebooks (one z70va and one z71v) with the exact same specs (except one having the x700 and the other having the 6600), the z70va will outperform the z71v?

Some hard numbers would be preferable please (benchmarks, fps numbers in specific games), instead of just subjective evaluation.
post #20 of 28
video benchmarks run higher in the Z70va (2300-2700 in 3DMark05) than the Z71v (1700-2300 in 3DMark05), but I don't know if there's any significant difference in actual gameplay. Performance in other areas should be nearly identical.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Asus Notebook Reviews
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Forums › Asus Notebook Reviews › Review: Seppuku's z70va “refresh” Review