NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › What Powerbook do you recommend?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

What Powerbook do you recommend?

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I am can get an Apple from work and I can get any Apple laptop I want. I can get an iBook or Powerbook, but money is not an issue. I choose a PowerBook.

So now the question is do I get a 12 or 15 inch version? The 17 inch is too big for me.

I realize that the size is a personal question that only I can answer, but I wanted to hear your opinions on the other specs.

I have been reading these forums and I have a somewhat understanding. Please correct me or add

-I realize that the Apple laptops may not be gaming machines. Does the ATI mobility 9700 offer a great improvement in that regard? Does the 9700 offer that much more DVD stability?
-I understand the 15inch has newer technology (like the DDR2 4200 and more max memory). Is it that important for overall performance?
-The 15 incher also has the optional 7200 RPM drive. I have seen some of the benchies for WinXP and 4200, 5400, 7200RPM and the 7200RPM is definately faster. I suppose it would be important if everything else meshed well. What do you think?
-Do the sum of these parts make the 15 inch Powerbook a much better performer? If you can put a relative increase in overall performance, what would it be (i.e. it is 1.1x or 2 times)?

I would use the computer for simple stuff, like surfing the web, watching a DVD, writing papers, simple (occasional and really basic) video editing, listening to music. Nothing too taxing.

However, if the 15 incher does offer a significant leg up from th 12inch for games . . . I would be tempted to play games on it, in the down time. Games like WoW or Civ4, no FPS or games like Black and White 2.

A little more about myself, I also have a Dell 700m which most likely will be replaced with the Apple. I also have a killer XP based gaming desktop, so gaming on the go is not that important, and I am looking forward to getting the Xbox 360. I believe I have my gaming solved, but gaming on the go . . . . I dunno, never done it.

Even more, if you believe that something else is around the corner, please let me know. I need to spend this money or it disappears. I have about 4 months to do it. I know the Mactels are coming, but in that time frame I do not believe I can use this money for them.

Edit: If everything being equal, you guys think the 12 inch iBook is better suited for me then I can get that and spend the money elsewhere. It is "my money" but I can not get it as a check. It is my expense account.


Guys, I appreciate your opinions.

Liver
post #2 of 5
Thread Starter 

Or is this true

Mactels appearing in January as reported by Forbes?

Liver
post #3 of 5
The 15 is a better deal than the 12, and it has a much higher resolution screen. I'd only get the 12 if I needed something really portable.

There are rumours of the Macintels coming out in January, but I wouldn't hedge any bets on them being true.
post #4 of 5
yes, i would get the 15" as well... the 12 incher hasn't been updated in a while, and is starting to show its age
post #5 of 5
15" is the way to go. Bigger screen, more real estate, better graphics...if you want to play games on it. I play WoW on mine and it runs fine. It does tend to run extremely hot, but the palms are cool and that is all that matters because that is where my hands are at. With WoW on my PB, I rarely use my XP machine except for the newest games, which I rarely play.

I too have heard about the mactels being released in jan, but I heard it was going to be the iBook line being upgraded. We'll have to wait and see.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Apple Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › What Powerbook do you recommend?