New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Sager NP5720-V Review

post #1 of 32
Thread Starter 
SYSTEM

Sager NP 5720
> Intel Pentium M Processor 780 / 2MB L2 Cache, 2.26 GHz, 533MHz FSB
> 2GB Dual Channel DDR2 SDRAM at 533MHz (2 X 1024MB)
> Nvidia GeForce GO 7800 GTX PCI-Express 16X Graphics with 256MB DDR3 Video Memory
> 17.0" Wide Viewing Angles WUXGA Active Matrix LCD Display w/Super Clear Glossy Surface
> 100.0GB (7200rpm) Ultra ATA 100 Hard Drive
> 8X DVD ± R/RW/+DL Combo Drive w/LightScribe Technology & Software
> Integrated 1000Mbps Ethernet & Intel PRO/Wireless 802.11 a/b/g & Bluetooth Module
> Integrated 56K V.90 Internal Fax/Modem
> Smart Li-ION Battery
> Microsoft Windows XP Home Edition

System Price: $2889

-----------------------------------------------------------------

As of yet I haven't posted any pictures. I'll post some pictures and complete the rest of this review by this weekend (December 3-4).
Until then, pics of the same model (I believe it even has the same configuration) can be found here: http://www.notebookforums.com/showthread.php?t=117063


ORDERING & SHIPPING

I ordered my notebook from Sager for two main reasons: 1) I live in Texas, and would have had to pay sales tax to PCTorque. 2) I read in more than one thread that for some re-sellers, the manufacturer's warranty starts the day the re-seller buys the system from Sager, not the day you purchase the system from the re-seller. This would mean it could be possible for the manufacturer's 1-year warranty to last for only 9 months. I don't know if this is true, but I decided to play it safe.

After much debate, I opted not to get an extended warranty. I dread the thought of Phillips-Magnavox as a warranty service provider. It seems that (for the most part) if a computer has problems right out of the box, it will probably continue to have problems. But if a computer is problem-free right out of the box, it is likely to remain problem-free. Therefore, if I had problems right out of the box, I would have returned the system - not gotten it repaired - and gotten an entirely new one.

Sager allows returns (for a 100% refund) within 30 days of purchase if you are unhappy for any reason.

The sales rep (Tony, ext. 107) I spoke with with very helpful, especially when it came to discussing what parts were not in stock, and how long my system would be delayed if I configured it with certain parts. I placed the order on-line on November 7, around 3:00 PM. I paid by wire transfer the next morning, November 8. I received my system around 9:00 AM on November 9.

I have to admit, I was a bit concerned about the apparent lack of a testing/burn-in period. However, I've been using the system pretty heavily for over a week with no problems.

The notebook was satisfactorily packaged, comprable to other notebooks I've ordered.

FIRST IMPRESSIONS & OVERALL FEEL

The 5720 feels solid. There is no 'flex' in the keyboard or display. It was lighter than I expected, since I had been considering a monsther like the Sager 9000 series or the Hypersonic FX-7. It powered-on with no problems, and was not loaded with a bunch a 'crap applications' like most store-bought systems (or Dell). I also like the main-body's silver color and the black lid - it's a sharp-looking notebook.

BENCHMARKS (3DMark 05)

As delivered from Sager, with no changes:
> 3DMark Score: 6805

After using Spy Seeper to prevent unnecessary items from automatically starting with Windows, I got a new round of consistently higher benchmarks. (Obviously this can be done manually, but not being the computer guru that many of you are, I find Spy Sweeper to be great for removing unwanted stuff.)

With newest Nvidia Drivers, cleaned-up hard drive, and Power Scheme set to 'Always On' (although I don't know if that really matters):
> 3DMark Score: 7010
> CPU Score: 4230

These tests were run with no overclocking.

HEAT OUTPUT & FANS

Temperature Range (degrees Celcius) according to MobileMeter:
> CPU: 40 - 54
> Hard Drive: 35 - 44

As you would expect, the higher temperatures occured after extended use, especially gaming. Max fan use never kicked in during Internet browsing or office applications. Max fan use kicks in after about 10-15 minutes of gaming, quits after a few minutes, kicks in again after another 10-15 minutes of gaming, and so on... Max fan noise is noticeable. While it doesn't bother me, I can see that it might bother people who are particular about fan noise.

Luke@PCTorque provided a firmware that allows you to easily toggle the fans between full and auto by pressing Fn+F2. Since the laptop has never gotten anywhere close to being too hot, I haven't felt the need to install the firmware - I'm content to let the notebook manage its fans automatically.

The notebook has never gotten more than slightly (and I do mean only slightly) warm to the touch, even after long periods of use. The power brick does stay constantly warm, although not uncomfortable to the touch. I took the plastic PCMCIA place-holder/cover out when I first turned the notebook on, and I do notice a slight breeze coming out of it, so apparently this does help with airflow. I have not used the computer or taken any measurements with the plastic cover in place, so I don't know how much of an effect this actually has.

To reduce heat and extend battery life, I am considering undervolting the CPU (as described here: http://www.notebookforums.com/showthread.php?t=70943), although I want to look into possible performance issues first. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

BATTERY LIFE

> About 1.5 hours of intensive gaming.
> About 2.0 hours of browsing the Internet, downloading, and/or office applications. This assumes no use of the optical drive.
> After 2.5 hours using the Audio-DJ control panel (with laptop closed) at a fiarly low volume, 10% battery charge remained.

To reduce heat and extend battery life, I am considering undervolting the CPU (as described here: http://www.notebookforums.com/showthread.php?t=70943), although I want to look into possible performance issues first. Anyone have any thoughts on this?

DISPLAY

Granted, I got my previous laptop over a year ago, and it has only a 15" display, without the glossy surface, but...

This is best damn looking display I've seen. It's nicer than even my desktop's Dell 18" Flat Panel monitor. The contrast it amazing - everything is crystal clear with vibrant colors. The same screenshot on either my previous notebook or desktop looks dull in comparison.

Some reviews caution potential buyers that the 'glossy' (or whatever term is used by a particular manufacturer) screens can have bad glare/reflection problems. I have not noticed this to be an issue.

There are no dead/stuck pixels and no leaking/shadowing - even though I did not get the 0-dead pixel policy.

Personally, I find text and icon size to be ridiculsouly small when the display is set to its maximum resolution of 1920 x 1200. But if you don't mind the small size - and like to fit alot of stuff on your desktop - this is the screen for you.

I have my resolution set at 1280 x 800. I generally have game settings at 1084 x 768, which of course means the image needs to be 'stretched' horizontally to fill the entire screen. I thought the resulting distortion would bug me, but so far it hasn't really been noticeable during gameplay.

SOUND

Obviously the integrated speakers aren't as nice as your average Altec Lansing 8.1 surround sound system with subwoofer. However, I'm not going to defeat the whole purpose of a laptop by getting an external sound card and speakers. (I hate cords WITH A PASSION!!)

That being said, the integrated sound and speakers are definately above-average for a notebook - more than satisfactory for me.

In addition to the Control Panel and individual software applications, volume can be easily adjusted via Fn keys or the Audio-DJ panel. However, the Audio-DJ panel doesn't seem to operate when running games in full-screen mode. Perhaps that can be changed by altering settings, but I don't know because I haven't looked into it.

KEYBOARD

Great balance - has a solid feel with a little bit of a 'click' sound, but not too 'stiff' or loud. No particularly hot areas.

The built-in keypad (number-pad, 10-keypad, or whatever you call it) seems to be arranged a bit awkwardly, but I've gotten used to it and use it with no problems. Keep in mind however that I don't use it for heavy data entry or bookkeeping - but it's good for general office applications and gaming.

TOUCHPAD

The touchpad is made with a great material. It operates very smoothly (both during pointer movement and page-scrolling), and the snsetivity can be easily adjusted via the control panel. It has a bar (marked with up- and down-arrows) for vertical page-scrolling on the right hand side, although this can be disabled to allow the entire touch-pad to be for regular pointer movement only. It does not have a similar marked bar for horizontal scrolling, but you can confugire (via the control panel) an area to be used for horizontal page-scrolling if you wish. I use the touchpad and vertical scroll bar at default settings.

I only rarely accidentally hit the touchpad during typing, causing it to move the cursor. Luke@PCTorque (Luke is just awesome, ain't he?) provided a firmware that allows you to easily toggle the touchpad on and off by pressing Fn+F1. So even if accidentally hitting the touchpad when typing is an issue with you, the problem can be easily solved. I've downloaded the firmware, but haven't felt the need to install it.

Between the standard left-click and right-click buttons is a 'directional' button. To be honest, I've never used this button and am not entirely sure what its intended purpose is. But I bet it will make some function even more convienient once I figure it out. Someone, please feel free to let me know what this if for - and save me the trouble of actually reading the manual!

I'll complete the rest of this review by this weekend (December 3-4). Let me know if I've missed anything, or if there is something in particular you would like to know.

LED STATUS PANEL & AUDIO-DJ CONTROLS

CAMERA & MICROPHONE

WIRELESS & BLUETOOTH
LL
post #2 of 32
wow u got her fully loaded huh?
post #3 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Gary Pandher
wow u got her fully loaded huh?
Pretty much, with the exception of a TV-Tuner.

Your system doesn't look too shabby.....

Is the ATI 9700 a mobile video card?
post #4 of 32
DOH!!! another one with an extra .26 GHz and more RAM!!!

nice start on the review!
post #5 of 32
Great review
my score was 6730 and iam using 2.0GHZ ,my brother 5720 like your 2.26 and hes score was 6808,so is 350$ extra worth that mony in 3d games or maybe in some programes well run faster ?
post #6 of 32

One of the best reviews I've seen anyone do on this laptop

Thanks Hoss for the great info. I know most peole don't care about battery life and other stuff said, but I do and you have helped me make my decision. You rock!!!
post #7 of 32
Good stuff so far Hoss and thanks for posting it. Makes me more anxious to get mine.

As mentioned in another thread, I went with the 2.0. I didn't think the $350 was worth that much more (sorta what Super KW is asking about). That kept the system right near the $3k mark, which was very workable for me. If the USPS had followed through more timely, this may be a different story.

In any case, take some pictures in action like doc did. Since my system is going to look like yours, I can get more anxious for the arrival.

Looking forward to reading more. Thanks again.
post #8 of 32
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Super KW
Great review
my score was 6730 and iam using 2.0GHZ ,my brother 5720 like your 2.26 and hes score was 6808,so is 350$ extra worth that mony in 3d games or maybe in some programes well run faster ?
Quote:
Originally Posted by ratmyr
As mentioned in another thread, I went with the 2.26. I didn't think the $350 was worth that much more (sorta what Super KW is asking about).
If I'd stopped to think about it, I probably wouldn't have selected the slight CPU increase of .26 MHz for the more-than-slight price increase of $355.

But as I've whined about elsewhere (like here and here) I went with the 5720 after originally planning to go with a $5K Hypersonic FX7. (I have since given up on Hypersonic, and have cancelled that order.) After originally planning on spending $5K, the NP5720 at less than $3K (even with all the upgrades) seemed cheap!

Hmmm....I wonder if my wife agrees with my definition of "cheap"?
post #9 of 32
Thread Starter 

New Benchmark Scores!!!

I sat down over the holidays and really cleaned up my hard drive, preventing several items from automatically starting with Windows. After doing this, I re-ran 3DMark 05, and got new high scores!!

3DMark 05 3DMark Score: 7010

3dMark 05 CPUScore: 4230

How do you like them apples?!?!
post #10 of 32
Hoss, could you pls tell me how you avoid hitting your touchpad while typing? It's a major problem for me. Also, do you also have "blind" areas on the touchpad where it ignores anything you (anything within ~half an inch from the border the touchpad)?

Thx!
post #11 of 32
Thread Starter 
lomendil,

Fortunately, my hands just seem to naturally lie on either side of the touchapd. Occasionaly (rarely) the area around the juncture of my left palm & thumb hits the touchpad when I'm typing, but this occurs seldom enough that it's not an issue. I'm just lucky, I guess.

Any now that you mention it, the bottom-most and left-most 1/4" or so of the touchpad are not responive about half of time. Apparently I don't utilize the extreme edges of the touchpad enough to have noticed this before. Hmmmm...... I'm wondering if I should be upset about this even though I never noticed it before.

However, there is one touchpad issue that is annoying me - one that I hadn't yet discovered when I initially wrote the review. I don't like scrolling with the edge of the touchpad - instead, I prefer to use the middle "directional" button for scrolling. So I go into the Control Panel and disable scrolling with the edge of the touchpad. Everything works great - until I restart the computer. After restarting, the edge of the touchpad scrolls, even though the Control Panel settings indicate that function is disabled. I have to enable scrolling, hit 'apply', and then disable scrolling again each time I start the computer.

Anyone have an opinion on how to fix this? A new driver maybe?
post #12 of 32
Have you observed the same irregular headphone hiss (not the squeeks from the IrDA)?

Originally, I thought that the direction pad was for use in watching DVD videos without booting Windows. I've seen many other notebooks do this. But after attempting it last night, I discovered that DVDs cannot play without booting the computer. The ADJ functions are only for audio, not DVD video.

[petpeeve-rant]
(And BTW, contrary to what Disney and Wal-Mart think, DVDs are videos, and what they call "videos" are really VHS.)
[/petpeeve-rant]
post #13 of 32
Thread Starter 
I haven't noticed any hissing sound.

I've been really impressed with the laptop's integrated sound, both though headphones and the lappy's built-in speakers.
post #14 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by lomendil
Hoss, could you pls tell me how you avoid hitting your touchpad while typing? It's a major problem for me. Also, do you also have "blind" areas on the touchpad where it ignores anything you (anything within ~half an inch from the border the touchpad)?

Thx!
Not sure how long you've been using laptops, but with my first lappy I had that same problem... I'd always interject my typing into the middle of my text 'cause I'd accidentally clicked the touchpad. However, with more laptop use, I just got used to keeping my dumb ol' thumbs out of the way.
post #15 of 32
Have you tried to overclock the CPU in the BIOS?
In my lappy I can set the FSB to 153.
post #16 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ü09
Have you tried to overclock the CPU in the BIOS?
In my lappy I can set the FSB to 153.
My god, you are brave.
post #17 of 32
im so jelious...
post #18 of 32
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ü09
Have you tried to overclock the CPU in the BIOS?
In my lappy I can set the FSB to 153.

I have exactly the same Notebook also from Cyber-System.
But i do not have any OC.options in BIOS. I updated Firmware but
the OC-Options are stil not IN!!!

Which BIOS Rev. are on your Books? Mine was shipped with 1.02

Is it possible, that there are different Versions of the Clevo M570A?

Also i noticed, that CPU-Z recognized my CPU as an Dothan instead of the ordererd Sonoma?!?! Is this normal? I´m not sure whether Sonoma is just the new Centrino "Bundle" or is it the CPU only. If this is so, the actual Version of CPU-Z should read it right.
post #19 of 32
@prronto:

Yo, here is DaSmokingGNU from HWLuxx.
I´ll think you know my answer from HWluxx-forum.

Sonoma is the new platform "bundle", the CPU-name is Dothan.
So it seems to be all right.
post #20 of 32
i overclocked my 5720 15% ihave 2.0GHZ oc 2.3GHZ and the ram oc to 677 MHZ
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Sager & Clevo Notebook Reviews