NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Dell Forums › Dell Notebook Reviews › XPS M140 -- Awesome but worthless
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

XPS M140 -- Awesome but worthless

post #1 of 56
Thread Starter 
This is a great laptop. Light but not too light, 4 USB 2.0 ports, card readers, 5+ hours battery life, a touchpad with just the perfect sensitivity -- just, awesome.

Except.

After using the laptop for a full day, I have confirmed/decided that the screen is simply unusable for my purposes. Everything else about the laptop is wonderful. But there's no way I could use it for word processing or web design -- whites and light greys are indistinguishable at any brightness level, and (the bigger problem) the literally headache-inducing graininess makes all white backgrounds appear to shimmer with a layer of multicolored dust. I have been a computer professional for more than a decade and this is the worst laptop screen I have ever seen, by any manufacturer, in my life. Every employee I showed it to in our consulting/design firm agreed it was unacceptable.

I thought I'd try and give it a little time, to see if I would "get used to" the graininess, but it just doesn't happen. After fifteen minutes of use, every single time, I would get one of those eye-strain headaches that feels like you've been doing those "Magic Eye" 3D pictures for too long.

Powerstrip reports the screen as the Samsung SEC3157. I ordered the "Truelife" feature, and don't know how much of the blame goes to that. If this is the only screen available for this product, I will have to request a return and full refund (the product did not perform as promised, and I'll raise hell if they try to tack on a "restocking fee".) Alternately, if there is another screen available for this laptop, with everything else being equal, I'll be happy to exchange it, or even replace the screen myself if given proper directions and tools.

I do hope to be able to keep the laptop with a new screen. But this screen, as shipped, is flat-out unusable junk, and Dell should be ashamed of itself for allowing the Dell name to be placed on it, even on a $1,000 model.

John
post #2 of 56
Thread Starter 
(And yes, I signed up here just so I could share my experiences, since this is the first place I found on google discussing the problem when I was trying to determine whether my case was unique or the norm.)
post #3 of 56
I had 2 screens sent to me and both were the SEC3157, and both just as dissapointing as the first.

There is mention of a QSD screen which someone said was really good, but there is no seperate part number for it. So until a new screen is used (hopefully by the same manufacturer of the 700m/710m screen which are BEAUTIES), we are stuck with this not so great screen.
post #4 of 56
Thread Starter 
Some guy on a forum speculated that they use the Samsung for the Truelife option and that Q_____ screen for the non-Truelife option. Did you try getting it replaced with only Truelife screens, or non-Truelife screens?
post #5 of 56
Wow, that is discouraging to hear. Esp since my M140 will be delivered in a few days. Hopefully I won't have the same bad experience with my screen. Here's my total No0b question - will I be able to tell that there is a problem with my screen? (Sparkle, light leakage, etc) I'm not stupid, (ok, maybe a little ) but is it really obvious?


Sue
post #6 of 56
Thread Starter 
Hmm well for me, I was shocked enough when I started using it, it prompted me to research it online to see if I was the only one with the problem. I found other people who had the problem, with varying degrees of bothersome-ness. It might depend a lot on what you're doing -- if you're watching movies and playing games, it's a beautiful monitor. But whites and light greys, especially solid blocks, look like they're covered in a fine layer of multicolored dust. Whether it's enough to bother you will be good to hear -- perhaps since you're expecting the worst, it won't be so bad to you, whereas I was expecting the best, and so was profoundly disappointed.

Another thing that's irritating but not a deal breaker -- if you type fast on the keyboard, your fingers "catch" underneath the other keys from time to time. You'll see what I mean.

John
post #7 of 56
I have had a 140 for about a month now and am not disappointed with th screen. Mine is not a Truelife sinc I wanted a matte. Powerstrip reports the same model number as others sec 3157. Wonder if they just put the shiny coating on the screen and that is what is causing the effect you describe.
post #8 of 56
what is the part number for your dell screen. i ordered a 630m and on the dell site it says theyre giving me exactly.....

UD455 LIQUID CRYSTAL DISPLAY, 14.1WXGA, GLARE WIDE VIEWING ANGLE, QUANTA DISPLAY INCORPORATED .

They have explicitly stated wide viewing angle. Also, i dont think it is a samsung screen, although ive never heard of quanta. What screen do you guys have? My part number is UD455, also this is the truelife screen. My 630m is supposed to arrive today, hopefully its not the samsung and a better screen.
post #9 of 56
Thread Starter 
Did you order the Truelife or the standard?
post #10 of 56
notorius213, when you do get the screen use powerstrip to let us know what screen it is. if this screen prooves to be better than the samsungs, i will definately be asking for another screen replacement.

again, the i-630m is a great machine, less the not-so-great lcd.
post #11 of 56
Thread Starter 
The Dell just site told me:

14.1 inch WXGA TrueLife™ LCD Panel

On my order detail.
post #12 of 56
for those who dont know you can check your display using the following link, , just put in your service tag to find out your system info

http://support.dell.com/support/topi...n&s=dhs&~tab=2
post #13 of 56
yes i ordered true life. and i will run powerstripe, i doubt that it is the samsung, more like i wish it is not the samsung.
post #14 of 56
Order details don't tell the whole story. The QDS (or is it QSD) part number is listed the same as Samsung's. The real deal is when you get the system and run powerstrip to correctly identify your screen.
post #15 of 56
im assuming its the same as QDS, which most likely stands for Quanta Display (Screens??)
post #16 of 56
That is the screen I have been trying to have Dell send me, thing was the part number was initially the same as the samsung.
post #17 of 56
Thread Starter 
If you have the Samsung display, your order says:

Part #TD508 -- LIQUID CRYSTAL DISPLAY, 14.1WXGA, GLARE WIDE VIEWING ANGLE, SAMSUNG

If you have the Quanta display, your order says:

Part #UD455 -- LIQUID CRYSTAL DISPLAY, 14.1WXGA, GLARE WIDE VIEWING ANGLE, QUANTA DISPLAY INCORPORATED

So, they DON'T appear to have the same part number, contrary to popular opinion.
post #18 of 56
Great, now to get Dell to send out a 3rd replacement in the form of Quanta Display Incorporated :-)
post #19 of 56
i still have to run powerstripe to confirm that it is the QDS model, ill let everyone know as soon as the stupid delivery guy gets here
post #20 of 56
Thread Starter 
I thought the Dell delivery estimates were lying when I waited all day for mine -- UPS finally came at 7:45pm.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Dell Notebook Reviews
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Dell Forums › Dell Notebook Reviews › XPS M140 -- Awesome but worthless