NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Other Brand/Manufacturers › Other Brand Notebook Reviews › Review: Sitti - IBM ThinkPad R50P Review
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Review: Sitti - IBM ThinkPad R50P Review

post #1 of 36
Thread Starter 
IBM ThinkPad R50P 1832-22U

P-M 1.7Ghz
512MB
60GB 7200RPM 8MB
802.11 a/b/g
Bluetooth
15” 1600x1200
128MB ATI Mobility FireGL T2
DVD/CD Burner: CD-R/CD-RW, DVD-R/DVD-RW, DVD-RAM

Pro:
-Extremely Fast
-Does not get hot
-Very Quiet
-Best keyboard
-Long better life
-Very nice LCD
-Both of 802.11 and Bluetooth

Con:
-Quality is lower than previous ThinkPad series, such as A21P


Very first thing that I noticed after I opened the box is the quality. Compare to my old A21P, they are now using cheaper plastic. You can easily tell by just looking at it. Using the lower quality plastic is my only disappointment with this laptop. But still the quality is much better than any other laptops I have tried and returned. The whole laptop is very solid. Close the display and carry it around. You will immediately feel the difference.

I don’t know whether IBM is making their own LCD for ThinkPad or buying from other company. I just have to say that I really love the display. It is very bright. The text is crisp and clear. After I play games on it for hours, I have nothing to complain. Mine does not have any dead pixel by the way.

I am writing this review on my new ThinkPad. Even though I have a very power desktop, I love to type on ThinkPad. That is how good the keyboard is. I have tried Apple, HP, Gateway, ProStar (Clevo), etc, none of their keyboards would come close ThinkPad’s. But there is one thing that I don’t like with IBM’s new keyboard layout. They placed the arrow keys in between of the forward and backward keys (for web surfing). I frequently hit the backward key by the accident. I guess it is a matter of time of getting used to it.

Every other feature of this ThinkPad has, I love them all. It is very nice to have 802.11 a/b/g and Bluetooth together, which is very hard to find the laptop with these two. I was quite surprised with the DVD burner. I knew that it can burn –R/RW, but I did not know that it can burn –RAM also. You cannot put the DVD-RAM cartridge in it. You have to take out the disc from the cartridge in order to use it.

The new thing that is added to R50 and T41 series is the Hard Drive Active Protection System. I did not have high expectation of this feature, but once again IBM surprised me. It actually works. It comes with software that shows you the real-time status. When I lift the laptop very carefully and slowly, it immediately detects the movement and pause the hard drive until the movement stops. This will help to prevent the hard drive from damaging itself during on the move or accidental drop. Of course there is an option to ignore the frequent repetitive shocks for the uses in the car, train and airplane.

Games work fantastically. I tried the Simpsons Hit & Run, Postal 2, Call of Duty, and Unreal. They all run smoothly expect Call of Duty. Sometimes I experience Call of Duty does not run smoothly at the night map and crashes. I hope the future patches and drivers will fix this problem. Since Mobility FireGL T2 is based on Radeon 9600, I don’t think it would run any faster than Radeon 9600 on gaming. I have not installed 3D Studio MAX yet, but I am sure that you will see the big differences in such program.

And I forgot to mention about the boot time. Surprisingly, it takes only about 15 seconds to boot WindowsXP Pro after you press power button. IBM really did excellent job designing R50P.
post #2 of 36
I cannot believe that laptop cost 3849!
post #3 of 36
that is the saddest part! a great laptop at a HUGE cost
post #4 of 36
Sitti,

Nice review. Would love to see some benchmarks and pics if possible.
post #5 of 36
How heavy is it? I would love to buy a thin & light gaming notebook with a mobile pentium, an ATI 9600 Mobility video card, and a 60 gig 7200 rpm hard drive. The high-end IBMs and the Voodoo m:460 (which as far as I can tell hasn't actually shipped yet) seem to be the only candidates; but even though they're both well-built (not sure how IBM and Voodoo compare in quality), the're both really expensive.
post #6 of 36
Can you expound on how the UltraNav works. What functions do the buttons control?
post #7 of 36
Thread Starter 
The laptop weight about 7 pound with the battery. Maybe it is just me, I think it feels lighter than 7 pound.

Basically UltraNav give you two type of mouse: TrackPoint and touch pad. By default, both are enabled and you can use both together.

TrackPoint is used as regular pointing device. The blue button located in between of red left and right click buttons can be used for scrolling or magnifying glass.

Touch pad has a lot of features. I have not yet used all of these. Here are some of the info.

Tap again and hold to drag
Drag objects without pressing the mouse or TouchPad button. To drag, tap twice on the object and keep your finger down on the TouchPad on the second tap. Move the selected object by sliding your finger across the TouchPad surface and lift your finger to drop the object.

Locking Drags
The Locking Drags feature allows objects to be dragged long distances across the screen using several finger strokes. When Locking Drags is selected, a drag action persists after you lift your finger from the TouchPad. Tap the TouchPad again to drop the object and end the drag. To use Locking Drags, the Tap again and hold to drag feature must also be selected.

Virtual Scrolling
Allows you to scroll with a single stroke of your finger. Virtual Scrolling operates the scroll bars automatically so there is no need to move the pointer away from your work. Virtual Scrolling works with most scrollable windows such as word processing documents, spreadsheets, and large digital images. It also works with other scrollable items such as file lists and font lists.

Tap Zone
You can configure each of the four corners of the TouchPad surface to act as different buttons when tapped. Can do the actions below:

Left and Right buttons, below the touch pad, can be configured to do following actions:

Primary click
Secondary click
Middle click
Button/Zone/Gesture completely disabled
Jump to the start button
Jump to the menu of the current window
Minimize the current window
Maximize the current window
Scroll the current window up, or down, or to the left, or to the right.
Send a double left button click
Browse backward or forward one web page
Reload the current web page
Go to default web page
Stop loading current web
Press the Page Up key, Up arrow key, left arrow key, etc
Record and play a sequence of keystrokes
Run a program of your choosing
post #8 of 36
lol specs almost same as my F3000 but double the price =)

I suppose the screen must be better though.
post #9 of 36
Quote:
Originally Posted by StormX02
lol specs almost same as my F3000 but double the price =)
Well, yes, they are exactly the same (apart from the cpu, the video card, the screen, the chassis, and a few other things). ;-)
post #10 of 36
shadup, stop making me doubt my purchase!!
post #11 of 36
specs are always the same, just the matter of the manufacturer and quality.
post #12 of 36
Thanks for the explanation. Would you be able to provide any close up pics of the unit or print screens of the display? I've yet to see dual documents/window set up on the UXGA resolution.

Continue to enjoy your laptop!!!
post #13 of 36
After sitting on the fence for a couple of weeks, I'm thinking about getting an R50p instead of a Dell 8600. I think the IBM will be better build quality, support, and I like their port replicator.

Their keyboard, trackpoint, and buttons are much better engineered than Dell's. Let's face it, the keyboard and mouse pointers will get used more than anything else so it should be top notch or forget about it.
post #14 of 36
I'm also leaning heavily toward buying a R50p... the only thing I don't like is the spastic layout of the ports. I'm also a bit concerned about the video card... it uses a completely different driver than the Radeon cards, and if you look at the release notes of the driver, they don't seem to cater for updating it so games run smoothly as they do with the Catalyst driver. Could someone who owns one of these cards please let us know it they have any game issues with the Fire GL card?

Cheers

Luke
post #15 of 36
Thread Starter 

Pictures of R50P

Please click here

http://www.fototime.com/inv/FFBC5D79ABC8E7F
post #16 of 36
Thanks for that Sitti.... one other question... Where is the Windows key??
post #17 of 36
THANKS SO MUCH. I AM JEALOUS. The screen is marvelous, the size of the unit is great too. I've heard a few people speak about the issue of the plastic they use being "cheaper" than previous models. Overall it's still an awesome buy. Thanks again.
post #18 of 36
Thread Starter 
No problem.

All ThinkPad do not have Windows key. I guess IBM want to stick with old fashion keyboard. I rarely use windows key, so I don't mind not having it.
post #19 of 36
Shame... i have a small utility that lets you assign basically any shortcut you want to the windows key so you can launch apps, run macros etc... I don't think I could live without it. It makes the Windows key infinitely useful - it should be built into windows, that functionality.
post #20 of 36
Care to share that program? hehehe

BTW, nice machine but I cant see myself spending that much on a laptop.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Other Brand Notebook Reviews
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Other Brand/Manufacturers › Other Brand Notebook Reviews › Review: Sitti - IBM ThinkPad R50P Review