NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › Full-time Windows User -- Should I buy a Macbook Pro?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Full-time Windows User -- Should I buy a Macbook Pro?

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
Hello all,

I've been a Windows user my whole life and am in the market for a thin-and-light, but powerful laptop. My choice had been narrowed down significantly to either the Sony VGN-SZ120P or 160P, but I've been reading about the new MacBook Pro and their ability to run Windows XP as well, and it's got me thinking.

My PC is used primarily for web development/graphic design work right now. I use the Macromedia and Adobe suites all the time. I originally bought Photoshop 5.5 in college and have been upgrading it ever since (currently CS2). I have a volume license for the Macromedia MX2004 suite also. I also enjoy games, which is why I've never considered a Mac until now. I've always known Macs were better for development work, but the game thing held me back.

Anyway, I'm writing to get opinions on whether or not I should go with a MacBook Pro over the Sony. All the software I currently have is for PC (games, Office 2K3, Macromedia Studio MX 2004, Photoshop CS2, Quickbooks Pro, etc.) and I don't really have the budget to spend hundreds or thousands of dollars for this software on a Mac.

I understand the simplicity of Macs, as well as the security and lack of crashes, etc., but what else would make it more worthwhile for me over a PC? I think initially I'd be using the Windows side of things much more often, since I own all that software. Is it worth it for me to buy the Mac? It would seem not at this point, but I'm slowly moving into more of a developer than a gamer, so perhaps this would be better in the long run?

One other thing that's also important to me is a docking station. The Sony has one that would allow me to hook up my 2405FPW via DVI, USB devices, LAN, etc. very easily. Does Apple offer such a product?

Basically, pricing is about the same. The Sony is $2499 plus the docking station, and the Mac is $2499 plus a Windows License. What would you do in my situation? Thanks in advance.
post #2 of 12
I believe Adobe allows you to return your Windows version disks and replace them with Mac version disks...crosslicensing I think it's called. Or a crossgrade, something. Right now, however, it's best to stick with the Windows software as Adobe software won't be Universal until CS 3. If you upgrade with every new version you can just buy the Mac version when CS3 comes out. I'm not sure when the Macromedia stuff will be universalised but, again, if you buy upgrades as they come out you can upgrade to the Mac versions then.

An Intel Mac should be a great thing for web developers now as they can test their sites on Windows and OS X with just one computer. I say it's worth it to buy a Mac but I'm biased.

And there's no need for a docking station with the Intel PowerBook as it contains all the connectors you need.
post #3 of 12
I was a windows user my whole life and just switched to a macbook pro. I am a huge gamer so tonight I am installing bootcamp but other than games I intend to use OS X. It is much more simplistic too me and I bought Office for it. Now, I was not in your shoes. You have a lively hood, and relearning an operating system just to do the same tasks might not be worth it. The Macbook pro does come with a dvi connection and 2 usb connections, so not sure why you would need a docking station.

I have only used the OS X for a few days, but I already enjoy it. But switching just for the sake of switching (especially if you are just going to use windows) might not be a great move. Granted, later on you might wish you had the ability to use both operating systems so ....
post #4 of 12
I am also in this dilemma. Have always wanted to get a Mac but all my development is in the PC environment and all my software is PC based. I'm not going to change this but would seriously look at getting a Macbook if all my current software ran perfectly on it.
post #5 of 12
I do graphic design and Web front end web developement on both Macs (home) and PCs (work), using Mac OSX and Windows 2000/XP. It is really nice to have a Mac since websites do behave differently during development, there are bugs and issues that do pop up.

The problems with fonts not being Mac compatible is not as big a issue as it use to be, the majority of Windows based fonts are now compatible with Mac OSX.

Unless you are doing some specific Windows based developement like ASP.net or use a lot of DHTML, then working between platforms is less of a problem now.

So, I say get a MacBook Pro, having a mac around is useful.
post #6 of 12
I would wait for new versions of the Adobe/Macromedia stuff. The current versions are PowerPC binaries. They are going to run very slow compared to a native version. Intuit did a rather poor job on the Mac version of QBC as well which isn't a universal binary either. Using bootcamp to install windows and slowly adjusting to OSX may be the best option for you if you really want a Mac.
post #7 of 12
Thread Starter 
After a couple weeks of deliberation, I'm definitely going to get a MacBook Pro. I'll use my current Adobe/Macromedia software on Windows until the optimized Mac versions come out, and I'll slowly progress to only using Windows for games and other Windows-only apps. Now I'm just agonizing over specs.
post #8 of 12
tj...

Once you get up and running, check out fink. You can find it through the apple developers pages. It gives you very nice access to a large number of UNIX applications with great package management based on Debian (Linux) apt. You'll need to download Apple's XCODE tools, and you should also install X11 from your OSX cd if it's not preinstalled (it probably is).

- Ed
post #9 of 12
My thinking was to keep using my XP/Vista and Windows based Adobe Apps. I'll only need OSX to test my web apps.

I want to use the Macbook primarily as a Windows machine.
post #10 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by vGolf
My thinking was to keep using my XP/Vista and Windows based Adobe Apps. I'll only need OSX to test my web apps.

I want to use the Macbook primarily as a Windows machine.
:O


post #11 of 12
Evil!

Transgressor!

YOU SHALL NOT PASS!
post #12 of 12
:-o

Quel le horreur!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Apple Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › Full-time Windows User -- Should I buy a Macbook Pro?