NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Toshiba Notebook Forums › Toshiba Notebooks › Satellite Pro L20 v Satellite Pro A100 for UK user
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Satellite Pro L20 v Satellite Pro A100 for UK user

post #1 of 4
Thread Starter 
Hello All,

I've been reading this forum along with another in the UK and have got some excellent info from both.

I posted a Q in the UK forum and received a couple of good answers and wondered if anybody here could add to them.

I was originally comparing three models (the above title plus the Pro M50 but I've since ruled the latter out as I don't need portability that much so would value a larger screen instead).

I've never bought a laptop before and my (somewhat limited) knowledge of PC specs is mainly desktop based so getting clued up was the task for the last two days after my sister said she wanted to buy a laptop.

I've used Toshiba's and HP's with my work and found them both very good machines. Looking at prices for entry level kit it seems that Toshiba has much more to offer so went down that route.

Here are the two shortlisted.

http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Toshi.../version-1.asp £429.96


http://www.laptopsdirect.co.uk/Toshi.../version-1.asp £475.95

My sister will be emailing, browsing, photo editing, watching DVDs output to the TV and some MS Office work. Nothing too taxing.

The key things that I wanted was a "M" processor, 512meg of RAM, DVD writer, wireless LAN and TV-Out.

These laptops are the minimum priced versions in their model class (A100,L20) that satisfy the above requirements.

I'm interested to hear if anybody has any views on whether there's any tangible benefits with going for anything other than the L20 at the lowest price out of the two. Does the other model have some benefits that are worth paying the extra for? Or can you seasoned laptop users recommend a better spec'd product from another top notch manufacturer that betters these models?


The screen display ratio isn't that important, not looking to be watching too many widescreen movies on it but will be using photo editing programs so thought that a 4:3 screen would better suit since digital cameras take pictures in the 4:3 ratio.


One more thing. I've read the horror stories about people buying LCD monitors and laptops that arrived with dead/stuck pixels and having to put up with them because they fall below the 6 dead pixels limit, etc.. I don't believe I'm wrong in thinking that if I've spent £500 on something then I'd like it to be 'perfect' when it gets to me; and this includes not having black or coloured dots littering my screen from the get-go. Does anybody have any experience in returning laptops to the vendor under the Distance Selling Regs for a refund based on the fact that there are one or two dead/stuck pixels on arrival? And anybody know laptopsdirect.co.uk response to this? (I'm assuming that I can carefully take the laptop out of its packaging, turn it on, check for pixel problems then carefully repackage it and it would still qualify as " pristine re-saleable" as per their Terms; or would turning it on trigger some Windows XP setup program that I'd have to get through to look at the screen, thereby meaning that I've setup the machine and it is not pristine and re-saleable?)


Sorry for such a long message. Thanks once again for all the info that's already been posted and I look forward to reading any comments you lot have.


Cheers,


Jon
post #2 of 4
Hi Jon,
I've never been to the UK so I can't help you much on some of those questins pertaining to local shops, but I will offer my advice on some of your other points.

I think both machines are quite nice and even with the Celeron M processors, they should do quite nicely for the tasks you mentioned. I've done alot more than that on my old Pentium 3 laptop and the newer Celerons M will run circles around it. Remember that the Celeron M is basically a slightly crippled Pentium M processors. By that I mean it has a lower cache (affecting performance in CPU intense activities) and some of the power savings functions disabled (it gets less battery life). The normal day to day tasks you mention are not cpu intense at all and aslong as battery life is not a concern, then I am sure the cleron will do fine.

Both seem to be very similar notebooks. There are some differences in the chipsets and stuff like that, but nothing that will that greatly affect performance. The main differences that you may or may not notice are the 15.4 widescreen and 4 USB ports in the A100 and the 15" regular aspect screen and 3 USB ports in the L20 (I doubt you'd notice the 0.1 kg difference in weight between the two even if you will be carrying it around).

So since you say you don't care for the widescreen I think the L20 will be just fine for you.

Regarding the stuck pixels, it is not that uncommon to have one or two stuck pixels, but then it is not that common either. Usually you will not even notice one or two stuck/dead pixels since they are so small, unless you have the screen entirely one color and the color it is stuck on is the opposite color. There are stories of people being able to massage a stuck pixel back to life and never having problems with it again. In the end stuck pixels can do happen with any manufacturer (inlcuding desktop LCD's), but if you let it worry you too much, you'll never end up buying anyhthing. I'd say just make sure the store has a good return policy. Then if for whatever reason within the first two weeks if you don't like the laptop you should be able to return it and get at least store credit.

Good luck.
post #3 of 4
Thread Starter 
g00nter,
Let me thank you for a very helpful and informative reply; I really appreciate it.

I hear what you say about the dead pixel thing and worrying too much to ever buy anything. It just erks me that you and your next door neighbour could go buy the same product and you could get stuck with twinkling christmas tree lights on your screen and you've both paid the same money!

Thanks again for your help.

Jon
post #4 of 4
goonter was right, but sadly there is little that can be done about the stuck/dead pixels if any come up.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Toshiba Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Toshiba Notebook Forums › Toshiba Notebooks › Satellite Pro L20 v Satellite Pro A100 for UK user