NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › Skimpy Schoolteacher Deluxe ~ Notebook Prefs
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Skimpy Schoolteacher Deluxe ~ Notebook Prefs

post #1 of 5
Thread Starter 
I'm not the teacher. I'm the friend who's helping. And the way I'm helping is to ask for help myself!

I know what I'm doing with desktops and software. Those are my own strengths. But my schoolteacher friend is new to computers generally. Her needs will be simple and conservative. No games.

However, people have a tendency to underestimate the power/speed requirements of multitasking involved with some of the hefty software programs combined with scanning and things. So, I don't want her computer to show her a lot of hourglasses. (I learned the hard way, with a desktop Cely 1.7 with 128 KB L2 cache, crippled by Intel. Never again.)

Also, even in an unpredictable, possibly short-lived notebook, I would add RAM. Just plain old experience. Let's suppose a total of 1 GB+ RAM.

My other concern is whether the typical (cheap) hard drive of ~4400 rpm is a drag, or is it actually OK? I've never used anything less than 7200, but I've never had a notebook.

She'll try not to use the battery any more than she has to. Basically, a very easy computer to config; a real snap. That's why "skimpy"—but she'll want it to be reliable, and easy on the eyes. WORD, Excel, Firefox (mainly researching, data, and her email). Possibly music (the teachers stay afterhours, doing prep for next day; often have music on their boxes while working—but that is not a huge deal). I'll put on a few memory drains like ewido and others, becuz these nice folks are notorious for using their systems in bad neighborhoods without even knowing!

So: If you're a schoolteacher like her, watch this space!!!! And if you know both notebooks and this kind of user, thanks for your suggestions!

Here is the cincher, though: price. Some teachers have lots of money. This one doesn't!!! So it's a matter of coming up with a nice but inexpensive-as-possible computer. For example, instead of switching out a small HD, I'm already thinking just 30 GB would be okay, and I can add an external biggie later or if she really does want that music!

Here we go. And thanks, everyone.
post #2 of 5
do you mean crippled by intel that you dont want an intel proccesor? cuz no cheap notebooks have AMD proccesors, if she wants a sold reliable notebook then she should get an ibm thinkpad, they are pretty cheap, solid and reliable, and another good company is toshiba if you want good average task notebooks, or even HP, just look through the lists and specs of notebooks on their sites and you will find one that suits her, or you consider a dell latitude or inspiron, which are good, cheap notebooks, but all of them come with intel proccesors if you dont want an intel becuase you were "crippled by intel" so if you want something else, its gonna cost you......
post #3 of 5
Thread Starter 
Thanks, polishman. No, she may well end up with Intel, 'cuz I have to put her needs in front of my own growlies, right? Haha! For my own, Intel has very effectively steered me straight over to AMD, because that Celeron fiasco was unforgiveable. But this is for my friend, not for me, and as you say, AMDs may be out of her range. Mainly I just want her to be very happy!
post #4 of 5
Well first of all we should discuss screen (and consequently notebook) size.

12" -> very small, very light but it can be a pain to use it for a long time. The keyboard usually isnt confortable.

14" -> small, light. A good mid range notebook

15.4" -> a tad bigger and heavier. Might be a bit too big for a woman (usually weighs 6.x lbs + power brick). It is usually the least expensive and offers a lot of perfomance/price though.

Well I think that the optimal screen for her would be the 14".

Now lets go through CPUs

Celeron, semprons, pentium 4-M -> low end processors, not worth it if you're buying a new notebook, especially because you can get a pentium M cheap these days. Stay away from these!

Pentium 4, Athlon XP -> desktop processors on a notebook = These make the notebook big, heavy and hot. stay away from them!

Pentium M and AMD Turion -> Now we're talking. These are very efficient mobile processors, and offer a great value for the money. The turion is 64 bits but honeslty I dont think she'll ever take advantage of that...

Intel Core Duo -> New generation of the pentium M, dual core and currently the best mobile processor available. Its expensive though, so unless you can get a very good deal on it, go for one of the 2 processors above


Now RAM, HD, optical bay etc.
They're all pretty much the same. Stay away from 4200RPM HDs, but the 5400 RPM ones are almost as fast as the 7200, and come with a much lower price tag. 1GB of ram will be enough to last her for quite a while. DVDRW are a plus but its better to save a few bucks and get an external one.

Build quality
This is definitely important, we have to look for something cheap but durable. The brand known to excel in build quality is IBM/Lenovo. They really set the bar for business notebooks and everyone else is trying to follow them. On that note, the business specific notoebooks like the HP Compaq, Dell Latitudes etc. are usually more sturdy and well built, wich is a big plus.


Ok, that was a nice talk, but the hell do I buy?
Ok, here are a couple of suggestions:

http://www.costcentral.com/proddetai...68938U/J86385/
$760 after $100 mail in rebate.
This one hell of a computer for the price. Core duo, bluetooth, xp pro, 80gig hd and its a lenovo..

For about that same price you can get a dell E1405, wich also comes with a core duo and pretty much the same specs as the above... just enter the coupon 3KD03B1213VHT5 to save 30% on notebooks priced at $999+

If thats still too expensive, check out this HP

http://shop4.outpost.com/product/4880360

$499 sempron 3300+, 512MB ram

Its a sempron, but the price is good. Might be a winner if you want to save a few bucks.

However if you can wait, there's always a good deal coming up. Take a look at http://www.salescircular.com/ to find some good deals on your state. Also try checking out www.slickdeals.net , techbargains.com and many others...
post #5 of 5
Thread Starter 
Wow! Thanks very much, again, Filippo! OK, I've been making notes, and I think I'll follow closely what you have suggested. Next I'm going to check out the URLs you sent me.

Best regards from Vancouver, Canada!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Notebook Forums - General
NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › Skimpy Schoolteacher Deluxe ~ Notebook Prefs