Quote:
Originally posted by atbear This is not true for me. I'm there to watch the game. I care about it!
|
Fine, let's say you are the rare exception that behaves intelligently during the game. That's still JUST YOU. Or you and your friends. As I said, I hate the -idiotic- culture around it, so then don't include yourself into my target population.
Quote:
This is not true AT ALL. I go crazy with adrenaline during a good game. Esp an LSU football game...
|
Ok, -THIS- is bull. Why? Because it's a direct contradiction. You stated previously that you DID -NOT- fit into my described category of people acting like monkeys going CRAZY around the TV. Or in the stadiums, where this can in fact become even dangerous. So it's time to make a choice, it's one or the other I'm afraid. They are mutually exclusive.
Quote:
Watching a sport can be all of that! Especially dramatic!
Again, not true. Just because you don't like to watch, doesn't mean it's not there. There's tons of drama! There's humor in parts... and for learning, there's human percerverance.
|
Oh... come ON! Dramatic? Maybe, I'll give you a 50/50 on that one, but FUNNY? HA! and INFORMATIVE? please. Yes, there can be some elements of suspense in there, but nothing like a good dramatic SHOW, or MOVIE. Think about this one for a second, because it makes perfect sense. Why? Because in EVERY SINGLE game that has ever been, is being, or will be played, EVER, there will only be THREE possible outcomes [In binary games, e.g. football, baseball, soccer]:
a) Team 1 wins.
b) Team 2 wins.
c) Tie.
Sure, the scores can vary, but this is usually irrelevant [outside of betting and gambling, which is another little "virtue" of sports.]
Quote:
And you should generalize like that, my brother started at LSU in Football, and I would venture to say is smarter than almost everybody in your Ivy League schools. He was begged to come to them... and he's now a top othopedic surgeon...
|
I am not generalizing. I did NOT say that all athletes are not smart. I did NOT say all smart people are bad athletes. I did not make ANY generalizations. What I DID say, is that the BEST athletes, the ones that truly go on to make the ranks of the legends, the ones that actually MATTER in a top-ten team, they are not top-notch university material. I don't doubt your brother is both smart AND a good player, but is he as good as [insert football god here... I dunno, Dan Marino?]. I didn't think so. If he is, then, my friend, you got yourself an incredibly rarity, and you SHOULD realize that it very, very, seldom happens. Moreover, [if he is, THAT good] why isn't he kicking ass out there right now?
[/b][/quote]
Quote:
Again, just because you don't like it doesn't mean it's bad.... I love it! |
Derivative lemma: just because you like it doesn't mean it's good either.
But fine, if you like to do it, go ahead. However, this thread was about what we thought were BAD ideas, and well, I personally think that's a really bad one. Let's not get too carried away here.
Cheers.