New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Gateway P-6831 FX Review

post #1 of 146
Thread Starter 
Browsing the Best Buy website the other day, the 17" Gateway P-6831FX, or FX for short, caught my eye, w/its Nvidia 8800M GTS video, and for $1349.99.

I had been just checking out everyone's 17" laptops for under $2000, just to see what's out there. Most had the Nvidia Go 8600M, and just one, w/the Go 8700M.

Anyway, when I saw the Gateway, I immediately did some research on it, and it looked very good, so I went and ordered it on their website, for a pickup at a local store on Friday. Saturday evening, pending rumors of a sale of the FX, when Best Buy posted their new sale prices, it was posted on sale for $1249.99, w/a free game, your choice, $49.99 or less. Sunday morning I called Best Buy and got the $100 credited back to my account. I picked the game Crysis, and it will be sent to me.

Looking at the laptop, the cpu is real easy to upgrade. The Intel 1.66 GHz T5450 Core 2 Duo that comes w/it, is really not that bad, and will do for now.

It has two hard drive bays built in, but w/only one is installed. With two hard drives, the laptop will support RAID 0.

The display is a 17.0" WXGA+ Ultrabright TFT Active Matrix (1440 x 900 max. resolution). It's the only thing that I'm a little disapointed with. It's too glossy, where an external light will effect the view, and as you move away from the screen, you start loosing the screen detail. Other than that, it's OK, and still shows very good detail, and considering the price, one can't really complain. The video out is a standard VGA connector, there's also a HDMI connector, but there is no DVI connector. On a good external monitor, the picture looks excellent.

The Intel chipset is the latest PM965, which supports Intel's latest laptop cpu's, including Intel's Extreme series.

The FX also supports Intel's new Turbo Memory card, but none is installed. I've read that there is no measureable benefit for having it.

Then of course there is the graphics card, the Nvidia Go 8800M GTS. In Vista, it is shown as an 8800 GT, but Gateway fixed that w/a newer driver, available as a download on their web site. It comes w/512 mb of built in DDR3 memory. The card appears not to be MXM, but appears to be soldered to the mother board, next to the cpu.

Anyway here are some benchnark numbers for the laptop:

Windows Vista Benchmarks w/the original Nvidia Driver 167.46

Vista Windows Experience Index Base Score - 4.5
Processor - 4.7
Memory - 4.5
Graphics - 5.9
Gaming Graphics - 5.8
Primary HD - 5.2


3DMark2001 - 20,049

3DMark03 - 23,269

3DMark05 - 10,060

3DMark06 - 7027

AquaMark3 - 86,673


Sandra Lite Benchmark (2008.1.13.12)

Processor: Dhry 14,187 Mips; Whet 10,488 Whet

Memory: Int 3670 mb/sec; Flt 3658 mb/sec


HD TUNE: 2x 60 gb Hitachi 7200 RPM, w/8 mb Cache HD's, setup as RAID 0.

Minimum - 37.8 mb/s
Maximum - 66.7 mb/s
Average - 51.4 mb/s
Access time - 15.0 ms
Burst Rate - 48.3 mb/s
CPU Usage - 4.9 %


Windows XP Pro Benchmarks w/the Nvidia Driver 169.32

3DMark2001 - 27,468

3DMark03 - 24,125

3DMark05 - 10,365

3DMark06 - 7155

AquaMark03 - 95,850


Sandra Lite Benchmark (2008.1.13.12)

Processor: Dhry 14,020 Mips; Whet 10,664 Whet

Memory: Int 3695 mb/sec; Flt 3696 mb/sec


HD TUNE: 2x 60 gb Hitachi 7200 RPM, w/8 mb Cache HD's, setup as RAID 0.

Transfer Rate
Minimum 9.7 MB/s
Maximum 63.0 MB/s
Average 49.8 MB/s

Access Time: 14.9 ms
Burst Transfer: 47.6 MB/s
CPU Usage 3.3 %





















Update: Well I got my two hard drives (HD) installed.

First of all, in order to mount the HD's, you need some very small headed screws, just like the ones that come mounted w/the original mounted HD in the FX. With all my large assortment of various screws that I've collected over the years building my own computers, I couldn't find any w/a small enough head. I ended up holding each HD w/just two of the four screws that came w/the original HD. I'll have to stop by a computer store to see if they have any w/that small enough head.

When pulling the stock HD, be very careful, it's in there tight. There is a plastic pull Tab on it, that has a tendency to stretch, and possibly break, if you are not careful. Take the small screw driver you used to open the HD lid, and carefully use it to wedge the HD out in back of it, at the same time you are pulling on the Tab.

Once both drives were installed, I went into the BIOS, went into the Advanced Menu, then selected the SATA mode, and changed it to the RAID mode, Saved and exited.

Rebooted, and a RAID Screen Option comes up where you have to hit the keys < CTRL- I > in order to get in and setup your RAID (RAID 0 or 1) and save that.

I tried loading XP Pro twice, but when it came up to setting up the HD's in the Menu, XP didn't see the HD's. It appears I need a driver for XP to see the RAID drives. I've got to go and see if I can find one someplace, but in the mean time, I tried loading up Vista, using Gateway provided CD, and it worked w/o a hitch. It saw the RAID drives and loaded the OS w/o a hitch, and very fast too. As for the hardware drivers, that was downloaded w/the Windows Update. No searching around for drivers. Vista was the easiest OS I've ever loaded, and very fast, thanks to the RAID 0, I'm sure.

Update: I finally got XP Pro loaded, using another external floppy drive, which worked. The only problem w/XP is finding drivers for the soundcard, touchpad, webcam, and modem. I could find the rest.

Update 02/23/08: I just installed a T9300, using Arctic Silver 5 (AS5) as a thermal compound (T/C), and it is presently running 40C, for Core 0, and 35C, for Core 1, unloaded.

I do have to say, Gateway did a good job w/their installation of the original T5450, in that they used what appeared to be a Silver T/C on it, as well as it having a good complete coating. Some manufacturers tend to not put a sufficient coating of T/C on, much less even use silver, but rather the white silicon stuff. The standard white silicon T/C works, don't get me wrong, but silver has a much better heat transfer than silicon does.

The installation of the T9300 was very easy. I do recommend using a Philip's head jeweler's screw driver, for removing the heat sink screws, as well as for the case cover screws, which can be purchased at Radio Shack (RS), as well as a small straight edge screw driver, for unlocking the cpu from it's socket, which too can be purchased at RS. Of course you'll need the AS5, or if you can't find it, regular white silicon T/C from Radio Shake will do. Before disassembling, take a small magnet and run the Philip's head screwdriver that you will be using, across it a few times, enough to put a small magnet force on it. If you don't have a magnet, look around for some speakers. Reason, the screws on the heat sink are very small, as well as there being a couple of small springs on it too, that can all fall very easily off, and into the case. Rubbing Alcohol and a Q-Tip will be helpful for cleaning the T/C off of the heat sink, as well as a tooth pick for applying the T/C. Take the tooth pick and apply a "very" small coating of T/C on the CPU surface. Lay the heat sink down onto it and press it down w/your finger, then take it off to inspect the heat sink surface for a complete transfer of the T/C. If it wasn't complete, add just a little more to the areas that didn't get transfered, and then assemble. Tighten the screws according to the marked number sequence on the heat sink. Total install was maybe a half hour in my case, because of my dropping a couple of the screws into the case , requiring me to look around myself, for a magnet for my screw driver. Other than that, it was a piece of cake. The system booted up and saw the T9300.

.
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
LL
post #2 of 146
great pictures. you may want to think about taking some screenshots of those benchmarks for our new benchmark system being released soon.
post #3 of 146
That is fantastic, nice purchase. Dell better get on the ball or I'm going to have to buy one of these. Did you opt for any extended warranty or anything? That's one reason I like the Dells - 3 year warranty, plus I'm Dell certified and can order the parts myself.
post #4 of 146
Nice pics! This is by far the best deal for any gaming laptop in the market today!
post #5 of 146
Kudos to GoHack for first quick review post and definitely congrats on your new FX, GoHack. I am about to get one myself. Do you, GoHack, or anybody know if the chassis would allow to replace 8800gts with GTX?
post #6 of 146
I haven't researched this at all yet, so forgive my ignorance, but what is the best "bang for the buck" CPU replacement for this laptop? I'm thinking a CPU in the $200-250 range? Will the system board support quad core?
post #7 of 146
HEY MSP,
I was digging around a little and found out that the chipset is supporting 45nm Pernryn Core2Duos 8 series and Core2Extreme X7900 so I do not see anything standing in the way of T9300 or T9500 Quad Core upgrade since Core Extreme has way higher temps and power requirements so the chassis are definitely ready and power supplied...maybe the BIOS refresh? If only GTX swap is a GO I am in for Gateway this year!!!!!
post #8 of 146
Are you gona upgrade that 1.66 cpu?
post #9 of 146
That's awesome! I'd probably use the 1.66 CPU for a while and then rip it out.

But there's a guy on my other forum that bought one of these and is NOT happy with it, check it out:

http://www.tweak3d.net/forums/tech/g...s-1349-a-31849
post #10 of 146
Quote:
Originally Posted by MSP View Post
That's awesome! I'd probably use the 1.66 CPU for a while and then rip it out.

But there's a guy on my other forum that bought one of these and is NOT happy with it, check it out:

http://www.tweak3d.net/forums/tech/g...s-1349-a-31849
Seems like the reviewer is just angry at Best Buy. That`s all...It`s pity that the bitterness carries the FX with cuz I personally went to Best Buy and "touched" it. All I have to state is that the keyboard is lot better than my XPS M170(OMG "lot" is just not enough)) and sound is on pair with it. You cannot do much in BB but click through vista desktop and run couple command prompt lines...even though pretty decent screen actually surprisingly vibrant (I have 1900x1200WUXGA now) with worse angles which I actually consider a plus since I do not really care for people watching my backup copies of Hollywood best. I have even lifted that "girl' = lighter than mine XPS. True, the battery is pulled out due to the security concerns... I will wait until it`s proven that I can swap for GTX(GTS=64 stream processors against GTX with 96 of them). Pair it with the quad core from e-bay and you`ve something BIG in front of you...And I simply do not have $3000+ for Aliens or Dell with nice lights...I wish I do but until than VIVA Gateway for their PRICE<Performance equation ). Good day, MSP


PS:TNX FOR THE FAST PUBLICATION OF YOUR REVIEW, GOHACK
post #11 of 146
Thread Starter 
I didn't opt for the extended warranty at the moment. Talking to Gateway, I can extend it w/them anytime before the regular warranty expires. I registered the system w/them.

I will be upgrading the 1.667 GHz cpu when the T9xxx series becomes available.

While the chipset may support the mobil Quad Cores's, Gateway will probably need to upgrade the BIOS for that. I'll keep my eyes open on the Quad Core's, since I'd rather have one of them instead of a Dual Core.

As best as I can see, w/o taking anything apart, the GPU appears to be not upgradeable.

I just ordered a pair of 60 gb Hitachi hard drives, which I plan to install in the FX as a RAID 0. I'll do some benchmarks on both the single 250 gb Seagate and on the dual Hitachi's, and post them here. I'll also take some pictures.

.
post #12 of 146
Nice review.

CPU upgrade is very worthwhile though and the 8800gts is plenty fast. I don't think Gateway will have a 8800gtx anytime soon, considering Dell is charging almost $700 extra for an SLI upgrade for the GTXs. T5450 CPU (4.7 Windows score, 1m 17.798s Super Pi 2M, 1455 CPU 3dmark06), T7500 CPU (5.1 Windows score, 0m 54. 712s, 1937 3dmarko6 CPU)

For those who are wondering, since this laptop comes stock with a 1440x900 screen, the 3Dmark06 scores are not the standard. The score is from the 1280x800 test.

This laptop in stock form, it's 06 score is about 7000 points. With my upgrades I got 8254 but with a 1920x1200 WUXGA screen and with the standard 1280x1024 res, it hits 7640 points. Oh mine hits 12642 in 3dmark05 but that's an outdated test anyways.

All in all this inexpensive laptop has a very big bite and is definitely worth it. Just have fun upgrading.
post #13 of 146
Yeah, it does appear his beef is mostly with Best Buy. And the rest could probably be blamed on Vista...

Just an FYI, I spoke with Gateway's sales department and they indicated that you CAN NOT add their extended warranty to items purchased via the retail channel, only items bought directly from them. Now I'm really torn. That Dell 3 year warranty is awfully tough to pass up. I'd almost be willing to settle for an 8600M display adapter to get it.
post #14 of 146
Hey MSP,
why don`t you order from Gateway then? I know it`s couple hundred more but than you`re getting better CPU if it helps to smooth the pain =). I`ve just shot an email to Nvidia if the chasis or laptops running 8800GTS are able to accomodate 8800GTX... Can`t wait for positive answer. Don`t get me wrong, I wouldn`t betray Dell but the times, when I`ve bought my XPS from them for 1399,- are long time gone ... Hope for GoHack to keep us updated.
-LtR-
post #15 of 146
I tried that as well, but according the sales people (at least here in the US) the P-6831FX is not available directly from Gateway.

Check it out, not available for purchase from their website:

http://www.gateway.com/systems/product/529667881.php
post #16 of 146
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Yeah, it does appear his beef is mostly with Best Buy. And the rest could probably be blamed on Vista...

Just an FYI, I spoke with Gateway's sales department and they indicated that you CAN NOT add their extended warranty to items purchased via the retail channel, only items bought directly from them. Now I'm really torn. That Dell 3 year warranty is awfully tough to pass up. I'd almost be willing to settle for an 8600M display adapter to get it.

That's not what they told me when I spoke w/them when I registered my FX.

.
post #17 of 146
Let's hope so. I just got this email from Wallace from their sales department, check it out:

Quote:
I am emailing you regarding the release of the new P-171 FX Series. We have them available now and I am sure you will be happy with the specs and the prices. I have put the link below so it is easy to find them.

http://www.gateway.com/systems/series/529598006.php


Please let me know directly on which model is right for you and I can see what I can do to get you even a better price than what we have online. You can respond to this email or call me at the number below.

Thanks,
Wallace
post #18 of 146
I've been chatting with Wallace. The P-171S FX comes with a 2ghz CPU for $1599, and he indicated they would negotiate. The 3 year extended warranty is an additional $149. Plus they're offering 6 months same as cash on the financing...
post #19 of 146
Thread Starter 
I guess the only differences between the $1599.99 Gateway P-171FX and the $1394.99 Best Buy P-6831FX, is the 2.00 GHz Intel T7250 CPU vs. the 1.66 GHz T5450, and the P-171FX having a Fingerprint Reader. Everything else is the same.

The T7250 is $215.00 at Newegg, so adding that to the P-6831FX, brings that cost up to $1609.99. a $10.00 difference. Of course the P-171FX has the Fingerprint Reader too, if that's important to anyone.

.
post #20 of 146
Wow, takes more than 2 months to ship
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Gateway Notebook Reviews