NotebookForums.com › Forums › Off Topic › Desktop and Hardware Discussion › first build since my 486dx!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

first build since my 486dx!

post #1 of 38
Thread Starter 
unfortunately, i don't have the cash to go hog wild. i'd prefer to get another laptop, but it seems kind of silly to pay more for less machine when i'm on a budget, and already have a laptop that's a perfectly serviceable traveling box.

ideally, i'd like to stay in the neighborhood of $1000. less would be spectacular, but slightly more would be acceptable. i'll primarily be using the box for gaming and graphic design, and would like to dual boot windows and some flavor of linux (i have not yet checked any of the hardware for linux compatibility, i figured i'd get a good starting point and then make adjustments if necessary).

my main question is in the areas i really know nothing about - gpus. i'd like to get a nice gpu, but have very little interest in having the omgsweetest thing out there. i'm accustomed to a mobility radeon 9700, so anything significantly better than that (which i assume is most gpus at this point) will probably make me pee myself.

anyway, here's what i've found in my brief episode of browsing (prices aren't exact, just ballpark rounded up to account for tax/shipping)...

GIGABYTE GA-EP45-DS3L LGA 775 Intel P45 ATX Intel Motherboard - $100

Intel Core 2 Duo E8500 Wolfdale 3.16GHz LGA 775 65W Dual-Core Processor - $200

CORSAIR DOMINATOR 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1066 (PC2 8500) Dual Channel Kit Desktop Memory - $150

VisionTek 900241 Radeon HD 4850 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready CrossFire Supported Video Card - $200

Western Digital Caviar SE16 WD6400AAKS 640GB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $100

ASUS VW222U Black 22" 2ms(GTG) Widescreen LCD Monitor - $250

Saitek PK02 2-Tone USB Standard Eclipse II Keyboard - $50

and BALLS! i'm already up to ~$1050, without a psu or case. (if anyone can recommend a quiet, efficient, and reliable psu i'd appreciate it.)

basically, despite all my rambling at the beginning, i'm just wondering this - am i spending too much in any area, or perhaps skimping where i shouldn't be? see any lemon parts i should avoid? i could also use some cooling advice before i start trying to find a case - do i need/want thermal paste for the cpu, cooling for the gpu, a case with ventilation aplenty, etc etc...

thanks

edit: i also haven't really shopped around yet, just newegg and mwave. their prices are essentially identical, though mwave doesn't carry the keyboard, and newegg advertises about $80 in mail-in rebates for my current parts list. any other vendor suggestions?

edit2: should i bite the bullet and get vista? or can i keep coasting on my 5 year old copy of xp pro?
post #2 of 38
Just off the bat, a few things you could pull off cheaper would be an E8400 instead of the E8500 (easy $30 saved that can be solved by OC'ing) and another big save is getting 4gb of 800mhz ram that isn't as premium as dominator. I think you could save a good $80 by doing that. I know you'll take a minor performance hit, but you can always overclock a bit...plus 800mhz is still plenty speedy.

-$110 for the win

Also since you're on a budget, I suggest holding onto XP as you may not enjoy Vista anyway, so why spend the extra money on it risking it.

Also some cheaper monitor options for you are

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16824009108

and

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16824001270
post #3 of 38
Thread Starter 
thanks for the feedback, pdonket...

i'll probably take your advice on the memory, and switch to the G.SKILL 4GB (2 x 2GB) 240-Pin DDR2 SDRAM DDR2 1000 (PC2 8000) for $80 - almost as fast, and half the price.

the E8400 is only $20 cheaper than the E8500, so i might stick with what i've got - i have no experience with overclocking, and although i'd like to try, it's probably better to assume my lazy ass won't put in the extra work...

i'm still trying to wade my way through the sea of monitors available - so thanks for those suggestions. though the asus is the first one that caught my eye, i'm not sold on it by any stretch (admittedly, i feel kind of guilty for not getting an asus mobo, i'm a bit of an asus fanboy)
post #4 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zem Frim-Bott View Post
my main question is in the areas i really know nothing about - gpus. i'd like to get a nice gpu, but have very little interest in having the omgsweetest thing out there. i'm accustomed to a mobility radeon 9700, so anything significantly better than that (which i assume is most gpus at this point) will probably make me pee myself.


Hey ZFB - you've got alot to choose from in the <$200 category. Some examples: 8800GT (512, G92 GPU), 8800GTS (512, G92), 9800GTX+, and the 4850. If you have the time to research, there are a few folks that have these cards (including the 4850 and 4870) for sale in the FS sections of several forums. You can save some $$$ here if you don't mind buying used.

If you want to eventually use X-Fire, stick with the 4850.

Power supplies can be tough, given the vast number of brands now available. I would look for something in the 500w-range for this setup. Since I like quiet, and PCPandC for quality, the Silencer 500 is about $70. Here are the specs.

Do you have a specific area for your case (ie. enclosed desk, armoire, etc.) where dimensions must first be considered? Do you want cool, quiet, or the best combo of the two?
post #5 of 38
Hi, keep an eye out for sales deals

I found the 4870 @ newegg for only $50 more than the 4850 - worth the upgrade for longevity

I got 2 4870s CFired and to be perfectly honest, one is good enough


http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814102769
post #6 of 38
Thread Starter 
thanks, buck and z.

@buck - is the only reason to pick the 4850 over those other cards the crossfire ability? i don't see myself going for crossfire, though it would probably be more forward-thinking of me to not rule out the possibility.

the case will either be on or under my desk - probably depending on how loud it is. the best combo of cool and quiet would be my preference. a mid-tower is probably the size i'm aiming for, though i don't have any restrictions for size, other than preferring a case that's both small and easy to work in.

right now i'm looking at this case, which includes a 500w earthwatts psu (rebranded seasonic, iirc). it's on crazy sale, is WHITE (why are 99.4% of cases black now?), and from what i've read, the psu is quality (linky). i plan on adding a hdd cooler (will also double as an intake fan, to complement the 120mm fan in the back of the case), and a cpu cooler.

i'm thinking that that should be more than adequate for cooling while also remaining pretty quiet (well, not too loud, anyway). thoughts?

edit: i had been looking at pcp&c earlier in the day - i'm still tempted to go with them (probably the one you linked to), provided i can grab it and another case i like (sans psu) for the same ballpark price. if the pcp&c psu was noticeably quieter, i'd definitely go that route...time for more research!
post #7 of 38
Thread Starter 
updated potential parts list: http://secure.newegg.com/WishList/Pu...stTitle=newbox

it's actually a little cheaper in my cart (mobo/cpu combo deal), and has $50 in mail-in rebates - so it's not too far above my ideal cost, and within my absolute limit for total cost (incl tax/shipping)...still researching though, so i might switch it up and pare back a little.

(the pci pcmcia card is for my echo indigo sound card)
post #8 of 38
Thread Starter 
from what i've read today, it seems like the 9800gtx+ is probably the way to go - especially since it can be had at newegg for the same price as the 4850, and comes bundled with a free copy of crysis...

it also seems that the 9800 runs a fair bit cooler than the 4850, which is nice. i'm a little concerned about having this much heat in a mid-tower case - am i just paranoid?

parts list updated. triple post. every minute i spend researching parts, i get a little closer to poverty.
post #9 of 38
Hey ZFB - will be on later this afternoon to get to your questions...

B
post #10 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zem Frim-Bott View Post
from what i've read today, it seems like the 9800gtx+ is probably the way to go - especially since it can be had at newegg for the same price as the 4850, and comes bundled with a free copy of crysis...

it also seems that the 9800 runs a fair bit cooler than the 4850, which is nice. i'm a little concerned about having this much heat in a mid-tower case - am i just paranoid?

parts list updated. triple post. every minute i spend researching parts, i get a little closer to poverty.
The 9800 would be a pretty nice card, but I would suggest checking out the 8800GT...I mean if you really want to stick to your budget you can save a ton by going with the 8800GT being that often it gets nice sales and MIR's. The one in my 420 has no overclocking and runs every game I run pretty darn nicely (yes, even Crysis).
post #11 of 38
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by pdonket View Post
The 9800 would be a pretty nice card, but I would suggest checking out the 8800GT...I mean if you really want to stick to your budget you can save a ton by going with the 8800GT being that often it gets nice sales and MIR's. The one in my 420 has no overclocking and runs every game I run pretty darn nicely (yes, even Crysis).
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Produc...82E16814130347

$125 after MIR, it looks like it sends hot air right out of the case, and it would make it so the video card isn't 1/6 of my budget...

thanks for trying to keep me out of the poorhouse, pd.
post #12 of 38
OK -

The reason I mentioned the 4850> 8800-9800 series was X-Fire. This is the first time multiple GPUs have scaled well (high resolutions)...to the point of worth buying (IMO). I recommend it if you 'want to keep your options open'. Yes, they run hot!

The AKIMBO-cooled cards, gotta say, I dig 'em for value.

If you don't mind breaking away from newegg, you can find better prices on cases. Just as an example, you should be able to pick up the case I have (Antec P182) along with that Silencer 500 for around the same price (+$10) as the case/psu combo you spec'ed (which is still nice). I like quiet, so I chose my components accordingly. I can't hear my Silencer 750 at all, that is...over my CPU fan.

While doing your research - check out SilentPC. A great source of info on all things quiet.
post #13 of 38
http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/...Card,2011.html

video card round up.

4850 would let you do a quick relatively cheap upgrade in say a year to crossfire when the cards are $125 level, but accordingly you'd have to buy a psu with that in mind for the future.

120mm case fans are much quieter then 90mm, I have noctuas, and you could probably drop the harddrive cooler, esp if fitting a case fan for intake somewhere near the hard drive

I have basically the same P45 motherboard and its great, but the last generation are pretty much the same and they sell one with built in wifi (P35 spec, asus P5). I saw an open box one for ~$100 on newegg

its easy to accidentally double your budget window shopping

cheers
post #14 of 38
Quote:
Originally Posted by ZX81 View Post

4850 would let you do a quick relatively cheap upgrade in say a year to crossfire when the cards are $125 level, but accordingly you'd have to buy a psu with that in mind for the future.
Definitely keep that in mind.

There's fans-a-plenty to choose from. I like the Noctuas ZX mentions, but also like Scythe.
post #15 of 38
Thread Starter 
cool, thanks for all the gpu and fan advice guys!

re-working my potential setup again...i'm not sure what i'll do with myself when i finally order something
post #16 of 38
Thread Starter 
updated parts list

wasn't sure if the 610 watt pcp&c would be adequate if i added another 4850 in the future, so i threw the 750 in there. would be an easy $50 saved if the 610 would get it done (and a $200 tragedy if it didn't).

it now comes to $1500 incl tax + shipping, which is more than i planned on spending, but not more than i can afford - this happens EVERY TIME i get a new computer

i fell like i'm finally about settled on parts (but still open to suggestions!)...time to start shopping around...

@zx81 - i'm a little wary of open box items, especially for something as critical as a mobo...am i nuts? i've seen plenty of open box deals that i considered, but in the end shied away from...
post #17 of 38
Hey ZFB - I've got a crapload of the Scythe S-Flex fans (think I have D's, E's and F's)...that I'll GIVE you, along with whatever else I have around here you might need. No catch - my wife is always on me about getting rid of this stuff (got a closet-full).
post #18 of 38
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Buck View Post
Hey ZFB - I've got a crapload of the Scythe S-Flex fans (think I have D's, E's and F's)...that I'll GIVE you, along with whatever else I have around here you might need. No catch - my wife is always on me about getting rid of this stuff (got a closet-full).
you're my hero; ygpm.
post #19 of 38
Nice Buck

Hey Zem, I noticed you have an audiocard there, check out the deluxe P5Q which has 8 channel on board - I'm not an audiophile - not even plugged in speakers yet lol - but worth checking to see if its good enough for you, save ~$20 overall

cheers
post #20 of 38
Thread Starter 
@z - i'll probably use my computer for listening to music more than i'll play games, so good sound quality is important to me. i haven't heard much good about any onboard audio, which is why i threw in the sound card. however, i'm seriously contemplating dropping the asus card, and going back to my original plan of a pci to pcmcia card to house my echo indigo. not the greatest for games, but i love the music quality. and $80 cheaper. if it's not adequate, i can always grab the sound card later...and i'm convinced!

i also just found a p5k deluxe that has sound and wifi onboard for $120. open box, but i still might go for it. more savings!

abandoned the sli/crossfire pipedream - i'm a 1 video card guy. lowered psu to 500w, lowered gpu to 8800GT. starting to feel better about the price

found a 8500/ram bundle that's $10 cheaper than the 8400 + ram i was looking at. ram seems decent, so i may go with that.

under $1200! (and that's with everything purchased from newegg - mwave has the p180 case for $80, maybe some other parts cheaper as well )

list

i'm starting to think that if i ensure good case cooling, i'll skip on the cpu cooler until i decide to OC...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Desktop and Hardware Discussion
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Off Topic › Desktop and Hardware Discussion › first build since my 486dx!