NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Audio & Video  › Notebook specialized for editing
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Notebook specialized for editing

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
In the last couple years i have become fond with video games and recording em',editing them, and uploading them 2 different websites. The problem is that my desktop is pretty much a dinasour now( no more than 600 RAM! !!!!! ) and am extremly limited in what i can do.

I need help to find a good laptop for a good value that can excel in audio and video editing which is what i will be using it for 80% of the time. i have no idea what to buy and would greatly appreciate your guys help.remember, EDITING. i dont know exaclty what tech specs would be useful for that and what i dont need thats just wasting my cash

by the way my budget is around 1k and im new here

thanx in advance
post #2 of 7
Honestly? At about $1k you are likely to be a bit limited. I would nearly recommend a Macbook, but while editing doesn't typically use the video card like gaming does, I have seen more and more video suites require a dedicated video card lately. For audio editing though it is a decent choice. I personally have a Macbook Pro I use for my editing work. Originally I did my work on my workstation, but it died and the MBP has picked up the slack nicely.

However since in the older thread you bumped down there you mentioned Vegas, I am going to assume you are looking at PC notebooks as much as anything(And the gaming as well points to that).

I don't have any specific reccomendations off hand, though general things I personally do...

Go to a store and try it out first. In particular, as best as you can, listen to the thing. Audio editing in particular is great, till you have to fight the whine of an overly loud cooling system to hear your work and can miss details like that. Plus for me it is a personal enjoyment issue, to much noise from the machine just grates on me.

I personally would not look for a desktop replacement, not even sure you could find one at that price range. One they tend to be loud, and two the battery life sucks to the point of you might as well get a desktop at that point. Getting a discreet graphics card is not a bad idea, and if you are doing a good amount of compositing and effects then a decent one would be on the list. I don't personally think going for the top of the line, newest flashiest thing, will work to your benefit in this case myself.

Get plenty of Ram. The more the merrier in general. I do my editing on 2 Gigs on my Macbook Pro, and had a powerbook with 1.5 before that, upgraded from 512 which I did audio editing on for a long while. I would say it is a good idea to get at least 2 gigs of ram for video editing these days.

A decent processor, but no so powerful it causes the need for more cooling(See above). A Core2Duo seems to be the best choice these days, a shame as I would love to support AMD more myself.

A firewire port if you plan on capturing your own audio and/or video. I prefer a powered firewire port, but the only other laptops I have seen other than Macs with that I tihnk were made by Samsung, or maybe it was Fujitsu. Been a while since I looked into it. For some reason PC laptop manufacturers don't like to use the thing which is more than slightly annoying for someone like me as it means I would have to carry around more wall worts.

HD space. For this I would actually suggest looking at an external drive. I am personally trying out, and thus far have been fairly happy with, a 2.5" FW400 Bus powered enclosure with a Samsung 5400RPM 320GB drive. I have been able to run a large number of audio tracks syncd to a single video track with no problem on it, haven't tried it with a video editing project yet, but eventually that will come as I turn my attention to rebuilding my portfolio again.

If using an internal drive, get a decent transfer rate. A lot of times this means a 7200RPM drive, but that is not always true. I chose the above drive as I had a choice between a 200GB 7200RPM drive and a 320GB 5400RPM drive. Between the two I think most benchmarks placed my 5400RPM drive as being quicker on sustained transfers but they were pretty close no matter what. It is just because of the density of the data on the plates that helps with the transfer rate in my case.

And a decent screen with a possibility for an external monitor is not a bad idea either. For capturing audio I would strongly suggest getting an external interface card. Even a cheap one will work much better than the internal on pretty well any laptop. Depending on the quality level you are looking for, a USB Mic may suffice(AT2020 USB maybe?) but that depends on your specific needs.

Think I covered just about everything. Let me know if you have more questions on any of this. And of course I would bet you will get more comments from others.

Seablade
post #3 of 7
Thread Starter 
another laptop the really caught my eye was the area51 m15x
( http://www.alienware.com/products/ar...de=SKU-DEFAULT )
which pretty much covers all your recommendations(except firewire, which i dont really mind) and i know i said my budget is around 1k but i am willing to work a couple more weeks at the local gocery store after school(if its worth it).

Im not sure about it but i have heard bad things, but also great things.Im mainly gonna be using programs like pinnacle studious to capture, Sony vegas to edit and also Adobe affter affects. Also do my fair share of gaming.

Also, forgot to mention i NEED a notebook because i am planning to use this a huge percentage of time at school and friends houses editing montages for them.Battery life dosent concern me sense i will be stationary during most of my work. so desktops are pretty much out of the question for me, and so are Mac's, im just to used to Pc's and there is just a thing about mac's that bug me and i dont feel like explaining.

So it would be helpful if u evalute more on the Alienware Area-51 m15x for me because i dont know much about it.hopefully you do. and thanks for everything seablade, appreciate the hospitality.
post #4 of 7
Well for the price of that notebook, I will be honest. I would look strongly at a MacBook Pro and put Windows on it if you want. It'll run about the same price, and be nice quiet, portable, and have good battery life. Since the recent Macs ARE pretty much PCs with the addition of one chip on the MB, there isn't to much difference, unless this thing that bothers you is in the hardware design? No need to explain, just throwing it out there.

In as far as evaluating that particular notebook I can't say to much sadly. I did notice that it does state it has a 9-Pin firewire port, which typically(But not always) will mean it is powered. So that might be even less of an issue for you, and if you want to transfer video from cameras FW would be highly recommended, as well as working well for audio interfaces. You might want to check who makes the chip driving it though. Preferably it will be Ti, but some chipsets do not work well. Something worth keeping in mind at least.

Between the video cards listed, myself I might look at the 8600 surprisingly in an effort to keep temps down. I can't recall the 87000 off hand, but IIRC the 8800 will be running on the hot side, meaning fans will be on more and more noise.

If you don't mind being connected to a wall all the time, I would go ahead and get the second HD to store your audio and video files on and work from.

Beyond that, get plenty of ram and it looks like it should work for you. I would recommend posting in the AW forum and asking for experience with this, in particular I personally would ask about noise levels.

Seablade
post #5 of 7
Thread Starter 
Oh my bad, didnt know there was a AW forum. Well thanks alot man, ur tips really helped. By the way, nice Avatar. Simpsons are sadly under appreciated these days.
post #6 of 7
Heh thanks. I actually am a much larger fan of the 'classic' Simpsons. Their more recent stuff has not been up to snuff IMO. Anyways got the idea from a blog that mentioned an online tool to convert a picture of you into a Simpsons avatar. Nothing great, but was fun.

Seablade
post #7 of 7
For over a year now I've been working as a video journalist and I'm more than happy with my Dell Latitude d630 for video editing purposes. As seablade already suggested I would recommend 2GB of RAM and a Core2Duo processor.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Notebook Audio & Video
NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Audio & Video  › Notebook specialized for editing