NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › Macbook won't boot..
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Macbook won't boot..

post #1 of 6
Thread Starter 
Ok, so a friend of mine has a macbook (Not sure exactly which model - though, I know it came with Tiger, and she upgraded to leopard).

She said she heard a noise like a disc spinning in the CD drive, the computer froze and now she has a blinking folder with a question mark.

I'm going to take a look at the computer tomorrow, but so far I've had her zap PRAM holding command, option, p, and r.. She said it restarted and did the same thing.

Then I had her try a safe boot - holding shift; no good.

Also had her try to boot into single user and verbose mode - neither worked.

Had her put in the leopard disk and open disk utility - the hard drive was not in the list.

The conclusion I've come to is that the spinning she heard was possibly something breaking off inside the hard drive and thus; the hard drive no longer works. Is there some other test I can try? Am I overlooking something simple? I feel bad telling her she has to re-do all the work on there because the hard drive is dead. It's under warranty.. But the closest Apple stores are quite a hike. If the hard drive is dead, will the Apple geniuses do a data recovery no charge since it's under warranty? Is there anything I can try to do a data recovery?
post #2 of 6
Check to make sure the hard drive is still connected?

If the hard drive HAS suffered physical damage, chances are that you wouldn't hear it spinning so much as grinding or not moving at all. In which case the most likely thing is that the partition table has been damaged. In such a case there are tools out there that can attempt to repair the partition table, but if they work I would recommend making an immediate backup and not trusting that hard drive again. To run these tools you would boot into a live cd and try to do so from there. You could also replace the hard drive and pop the old one into an external enclosure.

Seablade
post #3 of 6
Thread Starter 
Yeah.. Just went to her house today.. Was a clicking/grinding noise from the hard drive. I tried running DiskWarrior, but it didn't see the drive at all. Just to verify, I popped my macbook hard drive into her macbook and it booted right up.. Her's in mine, didn't boot at all, again, diskwarrior saw nothing.

Told her to call Apple and ask them if they're able to just ship a new drive out, or if she'll have to make the trek to an apple store.
post #4 of 6
Yea at that point, with a nice click of death happening, chances are that there is physical damage to the drive, and to get the data off would require a specialist. I don't believe Applecare covers this sadly, so you need to make a decision on whether that data is worth that much to you or not, and for Christmas or Anniversary, give her an external drive to use ONLY for TimeMachine and teach her how to do regular backups.

Sorry I don't have better news for you. This is assuming of course that diskutility in your computer did not see the drive at all(And not just can't see the partitions) if you boot the Macbook into FW mode and connect it to your computer?

Seablade
post #5 of 6
If it's in the one year warranty—or the three years from buying Apple Care—they will replace the drive. Batteries, however, are not covered under AppleCare unless they go bad within the first year and have not been cycled more than 300 times or if they're bloating andor leaking.
post #6 of 6
If she really needs the data she MIGHT be able to get a physical recovery for $200-300. More likely it may run her $500. My wife, then girlfriend, had her hard drive crap out on a mechanical failure the week before her law school finals. We didn't have a choice as she needed her data, so we sprung for the physical recovery. If it's just fluff on the drive, just take it in for warranty service, assuming it's still covered. And yeah, tell her to invest in a Time Machine drive. :-)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Apple Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Apple Forums › Apple Notebooks › Macbook won't boot..