New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

AW M15x vs Asus G73

post #1 of 15
Thread Starter 
Here is a quick comparison for those interested since I owned both systems. I will add more as I come up with them.

M15x

Pros
  • Great build quality. No anodized aluminum like the M17x but it feels really sturdy and looks good.
  • Nice LED LCD. It's no RGB LED but as far as LED screens go it's very nice, not washed out like some LED screens I've seen.
  • Easy to upgrade. The GPU, CPU, Hard Drive, Memory and CMOS battery are all accessible by removing the bottom cover which means removing the system battery and two screws. It's as eay as your average barebone system.
  • Standard MXM 3.0 slot. I was able to upgrade my nvidia 240M to an ATI 5870 that can be bought for Clevo systems. I was even able to use the MSI vbios on the card to activate ATI Overdrive through CCC.

    Pics of the ATI 5870 in the M15x.




  • Separate fan and heatsink for the GPU and CPU. This type of setup is normally reserved for 17" systems.
  • No chiclet keyboard which is a big plus for me....I hate the new trend of going to chiclet keyboards.
  • AlienFX which now interacts with games like Dark Void....very cool.

Cons
  • Might as well be a 17" system with one hard drive....it's as heavy as one.
  • Dell does not offer the system with the ATI 5870 only the ATI 5850. You need to do the upgrade yourself if you want it.
  • No CPU OC capabilities in the BIOS for the 920XM.
  • Huge LCD bezel makes it look funny.

G73

Pros
  • Best CPU OC'ing capabilities for a laptop. Not only is the TDP and TDC settings in the BIOS unlocked when using a 920XM**, setfsb works with this system AND Asus has it's own twin-turbo software which increases the CPU frequency from 133Mhz to 142Mhz.
  • Nice 17" 1920-x1080 LED LCD. Again one of the better non-RGB LED screens I've seen.
  • Light-weight for a 17" system.
  • ATI 5870 comes standard with this system along with 8GB of memory.

** This is no longer special to the Asus G73. The creator of Throttle stop has built this into his program.

Cons
  • Build quality is sub-par. I once bought a $300 MSI barebone just to use and abuse. The build quality felt cheap and flimsy...The G73 reminded me of that cheap build quality. The first one I had didn't even sit flush on my desk.
  • Non-standard GPU. Don't try changing the GPU in this system, Asus built this on it's own PCB board that is over-sized and would never fit in any other system. If you try to add the Clevo ATI card to it the screws won't line up and the heatsink won't sit flush.
  • Not an easy upgrade. To get to the GPU and CPU you need to completely disassemble the system and remove the system board. This makes something as simple as replacing thermal paste a long and drawn out task.
  • GPU runs too hot in this system. Idles about 10C higher than the M15x and when gaming if it get's too out you may get the dreaded GSOD.
  • Keyboard lag issues. Apparently this is a common problem with Asus laptops. It has something to do with the way the ribbon cable is manufactured.

Conclusion

In the end I prefer the M15x. *I wish I had the CPU OC capabilities of the G73 in the M15x but that is the only thing I will miss. Upgrade-ability, better cooling and better build quality is more important to me. I also had a lot of issues with Asus customer support, that is not an experience I want to go through again. So for now I sold my G73 and will run with my M15x and **M17x until there is a new toy out there to play with.

Update
*This is no longer true thanks to throttlestop. The M15x is a better performer all around with less issues.
**Big FAIL returned this also. Maybe I will try it again once the 480M is released.
post #2 of 15
Very nice personal take on these 2 systems

Is it worth to pay the extra $ for the AW then, if one can live with the "warm" side of the Asus?

cheers ...
post #3 of 15
Thanks Definitley like the AW line better than any other out there
post #4 of 15
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by qhn View Post
Very nice personal take on these 2 systems

Is it worth to pay the extra $ for the AW then, if one can live with the "warm" side of the Asus?

cheers ...
For me it is. I just sold the G73 and kept the M15x.
post #5 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by dave-p View Post
Thanks Definitley like the AW line better than any other out there
Quote:
Originally Posted by NWGuru View Post
For me it is. I just sold the G73 and kept the M15x.
Very cool.

cheers ...
post #6 of 15
So you would highly recommend the m17x?
post #7 of 15
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by darkloki View Post
So you would highly recommend the m17x?
It'll always depend on the need. I think the M17x is a finicky beast but once you get used to the quarks you start enjoying the RGB screen and the power behind two GPUs.
post #8 of 15
Nice thread. I just ordered the M15X last weekend and can't wait for it's arrival.
post #9 of 15
and of course we expect a review lol

that's for you qhn
post #10 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by dave-p View Post
and of course we expect a review lol

that's for you qhn
post #11 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by dave-p View Post
and of course we expect a review lol

that's for you qhn
Quote:
Originally Posted by qhn View Post


I will come out and say it now- I'll be doing a review of my upcoming M15X.
post #12 of 15
Quote:
Originally Posted by mb67 View Post


I will come out and say it now- I'll be doing a review of my upcoming M15X.
I have this in writing

cheers ...
post #13 of 15
Thread Starter 
I have a barebone M15x coming in now. I have plenty of extra parts to create a high-end system. I'm really considering using colorwarepc.com to paint one.
post #14 of 15
Can't wait to see your personal mod on this NWGuru

cheers ...
post #15 of 15
Thread Starter 
I would like to add that the biggest "pro" for me with the G73 is the fact that you can adjust TDP and TDC settings in the bios. This now works with all systems by using the latest (beta 2.70) version of Throttle Stop.

http://www.fileden.com/files/2008/3/...leStopBeta.zip
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home