NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Other Brand/Manufacturers › Other Brand Notebook Reviews › Centrino System - may be you guys can advise me
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Centrino System - may be you guys can advise me

post #1 of 25
Thread Starter 
Hi folks,

I am in the process of choosing a Centrino Laptop, to replace my current "Gericom" (European brand, I live in the UK at the moment), which has the same chassis as the ECS 736 and is REALLY loud.

The configuration I've thought about is the following:
  • 15 inch sXGA+
  • Centrino 1.6 or 1.7
  • 60gig with 5400rpm
  • 1gig RAM
  • DVD / CD-RW combo
  • Non-shared memory graphics
  • Win XP Home
  • WLAN Card

I am particularly looking for three things:
  • Reliable (won't be able to access support - going to Africa)
  • Quiet
  • Good screen (so I can watch movies and check out my digicam pics)

The ones I have narrowed it down to are:
  • Asus M6N
  • Aopen / Wistron 1557
  • Elitegroup G556

Could you advise me on the relative merits of these machines? Of course the Elitegroup does have better graphics, but that's not really important for me. The Asus sounds very solid, and I heard tons of good things about the Aopen... So I am a bit lost here.

I will probably purchase in the States, as my brother works in Boston and either I will visit him or he'll come over and could bring it. So availability in Europe is not an issue.

Thanks in advance for your guidance,

Cheers
Jever98
post #2 of 25
asus all the way, centino price drop and its getting the gpu upgrade june 1st i believe
post #3 of 25
If reliability is a real concern for you, then you would have to go with an IBM notebook, despite the fact that they are really expensive. In terms of reliability, I believe IBM is the undisputed champion.

I believe that there are 3 things that make IBM notebooks special:

1. F'ing expensive
2. Reliable
3. F'ing Ugly cases


post #4 of 25
I second Enderet's recommendation. If I were going out to the savannah I'd want a Thinkpad too.
post #5 of 25
Another thing I just thought of...

If your notebook is going to be taking quite a beating, and you need a rugged notebook, you might want to consider Panasonic's Toughbook line of notebooks. They are also expensive, but they sure can take a beating.
post #6 of 25
i can tell u first hand that the compal cl56 does not make any noise under general use... i cannot hear any noise from it when its in a silent room

the only time i hear noise from is when the dvd drive is spinning or when the HD is reading stuff

under gaming a fan kicks on but its so soft... its like... hmm soft is all i can say
post #7 of 25
Are you sure you can't get ANY support? One of my colleagues who just recently came from India dropped his T30 and broke the LCD (Everything else is fine but the lcd screen is busted). IBM honors his warranty here in the States despite the purchase was made in India. IBM's warranty is global. So long as there is an IBM office, they should honor your warranty.
post #8 of 25
Thread Starter 
Wow, thanks for the replies!

IBM is a bit beyond my budget, unfortunately, although I had been looking at the R50 (European Model no. - the one with 15" SXGA+, 1.5 Centrino, 32MB Video) - but that seemed a bit on the low performance side, since programs are becoming more and more demanding, etc.

Regarding support: I don't know which country I will be in, but I am not sure whether IBM can service a notebook in Uganda, for example. So I probably shouldn't count on it.

I won't be carrying it round very much, so may be I should take my chances (because of my budget) and just take one of the ODM Notebooks.

Which one would you say has the nicest screen (Asus / Wistron / EGS / Compal)?

And I gather that the EGS does have a pretty loud fan for a Centrino?

Thanks again for the help,
Jever
post #9 of 25
[quote]If I were going out to the savannah...[quote]

Quote:
If your notebook is going to be taking quite a beating, and you need a rugged notebook
lolol - Africa isn't quite that bad... well sometimes it is...

heh
post #10 of 25
ibms are really solid, pretty rugged too. they don't have to be that expensive either.
the panasonic toughbook w2 is incredible...a little pricey but HOTT.
post #11 of 25
hey, i just caught this in a cnet review of the ibm x40:
quote:
The IBM ThinkPad X40 is also eligible for the company's International Warranty Service, which you can use to get technical support in a number of countries around the world, from Algeria to Zimbabwe.
:endquote

might be worth looking into
post #12 of 25
Quote:
Originally Posted by grahamisded
the panasonic toughbook w2 is incredible...a little pricey but HOTT.
Unfortunately, the Toughbook w2, isnt really that tough at all, when compared to its older brothers, now THOSE can definetely take a beating. The w2 is an ultraportable, and while the case is made of a sturdy material, i would be afraid of putting it up to any test.
post #13 of 25
the compal cl56 that rincewind reccomended is a very nice system. IT has top of the line components yet with one flaw: the screen isn't of the best quality. Thus if you're watching movies or looking at pics, you may want to consider another alternative. The ECS is very loud and has top of the line componenents as well. The screen is better than that of the compal. Only bad thing is its solid 3 hour battery life. I think the asus is your best choice. 4-5 hour battery life; sweet widescreen or normal screen and a very nice video card. All for a pretty solid price.
post #14 of 25
Wasn't there something about the colour depth on the LCD of the Asus?

Shouldn't really base the ECS 556e on the voodoo M460... The voodoo was a P4-M not a P-M so, battery life should be down considerably. Atleast i think the M460 was a P4-M, dunno though. Also Guitarded and Warrenzai, both got the 556 and neither are really too upset at the noise level. (I e-mailed internetibuy they said the 556 should also get 4-5 hours, dunno how accurate that is though)
post #15 of 25
in all honesty here the screen issue is not really that big of a problem unless u were looking at a predominately black area... the vertical viewing angles do not really pose a problem when its color that your looking at..

now if u have a all black screen saver, or were playing some space flight sim with a big black screen you'd notice it...

all it is tho is the contrast/brightness not bein 100% balanced when at the 'sweet spot'

its off by maybe 10% top or bottom, but not both at the same time
post #16 of 25
Asus definitly. I have one and have had no regrets in buying it. Check out my review in the review section "my personal asus m6n review"

Actually two of my friends have the Toshiba Satellite and they say that it can handle the toughest beatings and still come out strong and beautiful. They have pretty good batery life also, you should consider one of their laptops.
post #17 of 25
i'd like to challenge some1 with a non sony xbrite fujutsu screen or high gloss screen notebook

and do the same test with a black screenbein displayed and the picture taken at low light settings and see if the blacks show up 'all black' on the entire screen

this is an LCD here, not a plasma or crt tv...
post #18 of 25
Thread Starter 
Thanks once again for the advice. Probably the Asus (Carbon Fibre Chassis) or the Compal (more bang for the buck?) will be it. Now I'll wait a little for Dothan processors to be implemented - that should work the prices a bit, I guess.

Since I'm still a student - does anybody of you know a reliable assembler that gives student discount? Would be nice
post #19 of 25
I know the college i'm going to next year has a deal with HP so that students get a discount on HP and compaq laptops, but that's probably a school by school basis.
post #20 of 25
What about an HP nc8000? Seems to fit the bill exactly here. It's very sturdy, is HP quality (not up to par with IBM but not that far), has a nice screen and runs both cool and silent.

An additional note about actual IBM reliability. I had an IBM six years ago, or to be more precise... The IBM notebook I purchased had a defective motherboard, and the replacement had successively 3 defective hard disks + toasted USB port + dead floppy drive + CD-ROM broke, and more. That IBM was nothing more but a very expensive trash can, I'd say, because apart the sturdy (and ugly) plastic housing, it had no other asset: what is inside sucks. Granted, it was six years ago, perhaps I was simply unlucky, since everyone seems to agree on IBM's high build quality; hope it's not another fine myth. I'm not buying a new IBM anytime soon, though; once bitten, twice shy.

And no, I wasn't molesting the IBM in any way nor was I throwing it periodically through the window to check how sturdy it was... I currently have a 4+ year old Gateway laptop which has no problem. Except the keyboard that is completely worn out, and the modem that doesn't work anymore; not bad for a laptop used over 10 hours per day.

Now, to get back to the subject (kind of), I have also done my research and here are my words of wisdom: if what you want is a sturdy, silent computer, with a good screen, get the nc8000.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Other Brand Notebook Reviews
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Other Brand/Manufacturers › Other Brand Notebook Reviews › Centrino System - may be you guys can advise me