NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › HELP! I think Best Buy is trying to rip me off (but what else is new...)
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

HELP! I think Best Buy is trying to rip me off (but what else is new...)

post #1 of 9
Thread Starter 
I need someone who is knowledgable about: laptop (PC) hardware repair, the prices for those said repairs, and dealing with the morons at Best Buy's Geek Squad.

Okay, first off, I have a Dell Studio XPS 16. I purchased it from Best Buy with the whole bells-and-whistles protection plan (I think they call it Black Tie Protection Plan); since expensive things I own have been known to have mishaps. Well, a couple of weeks ago, I had my lap top sitting on a chair that I bumped into and the laptop fell - cracking the plastic part where the charger is inserted into it. For a few days, I was still able to plug the charger into the cracked part, it was loose, but it still charged. Then when I took the charger out, the actual piece (plastic outside and metal inside) where the charger goes into came out as well. It looked as if two wires (a red and a white one, if I remember correctly) had been severed from whatever component it's supposed to attach to (I was told the motherboard). I brought it into Best Buy thinking they'd send it out and it would be a relatively painless repair. I guess I forgot I was dealing with Best Buy....

I got a call from them today informing me that repairing the laptop would cost more than the laptop itself ($1100 or $1200, I forget), so I can come in and get a new replacement laptop for that same value; BUT, bye-bye $350 protection plan. According to the protection plan, if the repairs are more costly than the laptop itself, this is the policy. However, I have a hard time believing that this repair is over $1000.

Are they trying to screw me over? And if so, what information should I bring in with me to argue this point? (Please keep in mind: I am a student, living out of state, in Miami. I am able to get rides from friends but overall it's not that easy to get around - therefore, I can't make continuous trips back and forth to settle this. ALSO - I'm a student! I don't have money to waste on what would be a desperately needed new protection plan!)

[sorry about the lack of technicalities when referring to parts...if I need to be more specific about anything just point it out and I'll try my best to clarify]
post #2 of 9
I would recommend that you request them to have a chit chat with the supervisor.

If the repair cost more than the notebook itself, then it is to their advantage to give you a replacement, no question asked - in my view!

Quite cheeky I must say about this policy - notebooks lose value after the 1st hour of the box laugh4.gif

cheers ...
post #3 of 9
Have them itemized the repair items and get a 2nd / 3rd opinion from other shops winknudge.gif

cheers ...
post #4 of 9
Hi!

I work at a repair center of a mayor brand, and according to my experience there's a high chance the repair cost is indeed higher than the actual cost of the whole unit.

I think they're not only estimating the cost of the DC jack, but also all the other parts that got damaged by the drop. Depending on the model there's a price for the parts. Yours is an XPS, I don't actually know Dells but I believe it is a high end consumer model. So, let's say...

  • Mainboard $400 to $700
  • DC-Jack $10 to $50
  • Bottom case $100 to $200

    And maybe even
  • Palmerest $100 to $200
  • HDD $100 to $300

Unfortunately yes, Best Buy's policy says that once they replace the unit the extended protection plan gets void.

Regards,
post #5 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by Ericko View Post

Hi!

I work at a repair center of a mayor brand, and according to my experience there's a high chance the repair cost is indeed higher than the actual cost of the whole unit.

I think they're not only estimating the cost of the DC jack, but also all the other parts that got damaged by the drop. Depending on the model there's a price for the parts. Yours is an XPS, I don't actually know Dells but I believe it is a high end consumer model. So, let's say...

  • Mainboard $400 to $700
  • DC-Jack $10 to $50
  • Bottom case $100 to $200

    And maybe even
  • Palmerest $100 to $200
  • HDD $100 to $300

Unfortunately yes, Best Buy's policy says that once they replace the unit the extended protection plan gets void.

Regards,

But the machine goes back to standard warranty correct? and the offer to extend the protection?

Time to find a 3rd party insurance, or review the home policy insurance?

cheers ...
post #6 of 9
A) How long have you had the laptop?
B) How long is the extended warranty?

I know you are not a lawyer, but have you read the small print? There may be some leverage there.

I tend not to bother with extended warranties as they are not worth the paper they are written on. The company always wriggles it's way out of it, usually blaming it on 'wear and tear' or 'user error' - but that is what extended warranty is for....!!!

The price of laptops has come down... What you do need is to back up any data - don't let them do it - that you need and take the newer laptop. Then add that to your home insurance...
post #7 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by Mr T View Post

A) How long have you had the laptop?
B) How long is the extended warranty?

I know you are not a lawyer, but have you read the small print? There may be some leverage there.

I tend not to bother with extended warranties as they are not worth the paper they are written on. The company always wriggles it's way out of it, usually blaming it on 'wear and tear' or 'user error' - but that is what extended warranty is for....!!!

The price of laptops has come down... What you do need is to back up any data - don't let them do it - that you need and take the newer laptop. Then add that to your home insurance...

Agreed, I believe that many electronic consumers overlook this feature and advantage in regard to home insurance - would save a lot of cost and headaches

cheers ...
post #8 of 9
Quote:
Originally Posted by qhn View Post

But the machine goes back to standard warranty correct?

We, as the manufacturer, DO honor the standard 1 year warranty on replacements.

I don't know if Best Buy does or even Dell.

Once I had a Dell replaced (after almost 3 years of use) under Complete Care Extended Warranty. The replacement unit was defective (dead green pixel on LCD and a few days later a whole green vertical line that ran from top to bottom). At the beggining they refused to fix it claiming that my warranty had expired already (which was indeed). I don't know about Dell's Policies, but after a few arguments they agreed to fix it for free.

Regards,
post #9 of 9
That is what I have been hearing in the USA. Once the replacement is done, consumers are left with no warranty to start over - better just to lease / rent a comp laugh4.gif

cheers ...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Notebook Forums - General
NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › HELP! I think Best Buy is trying to rip me off (but what else is new...)