New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

M6ne Semi-Review

post #1 of 7
Thread Starter 
I've been a lurker on this forum for quite a while now. This forum has given me a lot and think that it is just right to contribute something back.

I decided on the M6ne because I wanted a high-resolution SXGA+ screen for coding as well as CAD. The amount of desktop space is just ridiculous (in a good way). I don't understand all these people preferring lower resoultions simply for the widescreen "functionality." I also wanted something that wouldn't break the bank (no IBM), but also offered a professional design (flat black) and promising durability (all of my ASUS products have had excellent reliability). The ability to play the occasional UT2k4 match was also a deciding factor.

I purchased the following parts:

from Alpha PC Store:
M6ne barebone
Intel 2200bg wireless
DVD/CDRW
Modular battery

from Newegg:
1.7 ghz Dothan
512 mb pc2700 Kingston
60 gb 7200 rpm

total price ~$1800

Assembly was fairly quick. It took under two hours to complete. It would have been quicker if I had the guts to just use additional force to pry off the keyboard frame.

A current issue that I have is that the laptop seems to run hot over the CPU area and the fan seems to be running fairly constantly. Even right now as I write it is running, although at a very slow rate. I'll have to check my placement of the heatsink over the CPU. Power4 gear is set to Game and ASUS probe says that the CPU temp is ~50 C. Is this abnormal?

Several users have complained about the screen having poor viewing angles. I have a 3-year-old 17" Samsung flat-panel monitor for my desktop, which I thought had average viewing angles at the time, and this screen does pale in comparison. The screen does the job, however, and I can live with it.

The fit and finish of the notebook is excellent. There are some issues with the construction quality, especially around the palm rest area, where applying some compression forces causes the surface to yield. The keyboard is excellent. I've heard some complaints about flex, but I experience none.

Performance/battery life is consistent with other reviews.
post #2 of 7
Hi,

Can you post some pics please of the notebook at diff viewing angles, if possible.

Thanks for the review.
post #3 of 7
hey may try using speedswitch xp to manage your cpu settings... in Asus utility i believe when set to game... has the cpu set to high performance....
post #4 of 7
Quote:
Originally Posted by mister694
hey may try using speedswitch xp to manage your cpu settings... in Asus utility i believe when set to game... has the cpu set to high performance....
Actually in Game mode the CPU is clocked to 1000Mhz on the 1.7 model (the one I have). Also, my ASUS (pre-assembled) runs around 44 C or so when in Game mode and not doing any intensive stuff. The fan rarely turns on as well.

How's your 15.1" screen? I got one of the first ASUS M6800N models with th 15.1" SXGA+ screens (for similar reasons you did) and found that there indeed was a "gradient" issue, however I've come to love this laptop more than I need a gradient free screen.

Just wondering if ASUS has fixed that issue.

Thanks, and congrats on the purchase!

-Orb
post #5 of 7
Thread Starter 

Dothan vs. Banias?

I think there may be a difference between the Dothan and the Banias. I'm not entirely sure though.
post #6 of 7
manufacturing process is different (dothan is .09 micron, banias is .13)

tdp power is different (dothan uses 21w full load, banias uses 24w full load)

l2 cache is different (dothan has 2mb l2 cache, banias has 1mb l2 cache)

cpu speed (banias ends at 1.7, dothan has just begun and is already going to 2.13ghz)
post #7 of 7
Thread Starter 
Quote:
Originally Posted by rincewind
manufacturing process is different (dothan is .09 micron, banias is .13)

tdp power is different (dothan uses 21w full load, banias uses 24w full load)

l2 cache is different (dothan has 2mb l2 cache, banias has 1mb l2 cache)

cpu speed (banias ends at 1.7, dothan has just begun and is already going to 2.13ghz)
Please excuse me. I was being unclear. By difference, I was referring to the temperatures of either CPU on the M6n.

Btw, you forgot certain logic adjustments, such as replacement algorithm tweaks to accomodate the larger cache size.
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Other Brand Notebook Reviews