well I have a different take.
Reading between the lines perhaps a bit too much, what I see is a 9800 part that is more of a Desktop part that's been shrunk a bit to fit into a laptop type form factor.
A part that is way too hot and eats way much battery life. 
Read the tomshwardware review again.
This isn't a real true next generation LAPTOP part but some half-assed effort
for those of you who occasionally go to your parents house
or want to surf the web from Starbucks
but not for the rest of us who travel on an airplane and get stuck in thunderstorms, etc. If that's what you need then fine (no judgement attached though I'm being slightly sarcastic to make a point.) 
I don't think the next real true generation actual LAPTOP part comes until the post 9800 wave.
So the folks who are voting for 1st quarter 2005 I think are right on.
Reading between the lines perhaps a bit too much, what I see is a 9800 part that is more of a Desktop part that's been shrunk a bit to fit into a laptop type form factor.
A part that is way too hot and eats way much battery life. 
Read the tomshwardware review again.
This isn't a real true next generation LAPTOP part but some half-assed effort
for those of you who occasionally go to your parents house
or want to surf the web from Starbucks
but not for the rest of us who travel on an airplane and get stuck in thunderstorms, etc. If that's what you need then fine (no judgement attached though I'm being slightly sarcastic to make a point.) 
I don't think the next real true generation actual LAPTOP part comes until the post 9800 wave.
So the folks who are voting for 1st quarter 2005 I think are right on.







