NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Lenovo Notebook Forums › Lenovo Notebooks › Toshiba-CompUSA Fatal Combination!!!
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Toshiba-CompUSA Fatal Combination!!!

post #1 of 24
Thread Starter 
In August 2004 I bought a Toshiba Satellite A75 S226 from CompUSA. The next day I had to change it for a new one because the first laptop had a lot of dead pixels (like 20 or more) in the LCD. The second laptop was working fine but in the fifth month of use I notice that my laptop for some reason started to freeze. I reinstalled the OS using the recovery disk several times, even I installed different OS like Linux but the freeze problem persisted. Then the problem became a combination of freezes and a lot of blue screens. I started to search information in the Internet about the problem, especially from this forum, and I realized that these laptops have problem with the static electricity. I tried to reproduce what other people told about the problem but I couldn’t. I figured out that, when I touched the underneath area, near the fans, with a little bit of pressure the laptop begun to behave erratically displaying a lot of blue screens and errors.

I decided to take my laptop to CompUSA for warranty service in January 28, 2005; I paid for extended warranty in CompUSA. The person who attended me told me that it would be ready in a week, so I was pleased because I bought my laptop to work not to play. When the next week arrived I didn’t receive any response from CompUSA, so, I called CompUSA. They told me that the laptop wasn’t ready and they have no clues when the parts are going to arrive. They ordered a new motherboard. I told the technician that the person who receives my laptop told me that it was going to be ready in a week and he told me that the person who told me that is not supposed to tell this kind of information. After a little discussion they told me that my laptop have to wait for parts so they will call me when the parts arrive. Two weeks later I had no response again from CompUSA and I drove to the store to speak with any manager to see was is going on. They told me that Toshiba was confronting a delay with the parts due to the ‘extreme’ demand of parts for services, and the parts will take a long time to arrive. So, I was really frustrated and I told to the manager that I was going to take my laptop until the parts arrive because the problem is when I touch the laptop in the underneath area and I didn’t touched that area I was able to work on it.

When they brought to me the laptop… THE LCD COVER WAS BROKE!!! I called the police, I started to yell to the employee and everyone and I filled a recorded with the police about the negligent incident from CompUSA and I demand to the manager to replace my laptop for a new one of my money back. They refused to do that and they told me that they were going to replace everything broke in the laptop. I called the Department of Consumers Affairs here on Puerto Rico and they told me that CompUSA have to replace the damaged parts first but if the laptop persists with problems after that they have to replace my computer for a new one. CompUSA were not going to replace my laptop for a new one or return the money that I paid. So the manager told me if the computer was working fine I could take it to work on it while the parts and the LCD cover arrive.

When I started to use the unit again I realize that after 3 hours of use the laptop free zed again so a decided to left it in CompUSA. The hard disk begun to reflects some problems booting up, so they ordered a new hard disk too. I called Toshiba to tell all this story and get some response or solution, and after 2 hours of been waiting at the phone they finally attended me and they told the COMPUSA is not in their list of certified service provider and they insists that I MUST TAKE MY LAPTOP FROM COMPUSA TO ANOTHER Authorized Service Provider of Toshiba. I WAS IN SHOCK. Take a look in the Toshiba’s web site and CompUSA doesn’t appear in the list of authorized services providers. I called CompUSA angry about this and the general manager of the service area of CompUSA told me that CompUSA is certified but they doesn’t appear as a certified company by Toshiba. This not made any sense to me and I called my lawyer to start a legal issue here. My lawyer spoke with the managers of CompUSA in Puerto Rico to make any arrangement to solve this issue immediately but CompUSA refuse to give me my money back or replace the laptop.

Yesterday for my surprise, I receive a call from CompUSA indicating that my laptop was ready. I went to CompUSA and when I took my laptop I test it on the counter with the technician and the laptop was in the same condition, they didn’t do anything to fix the computer and the tried to return to me the laptop with the same problems and no parts changed.

This Monday I will sue CompUSA for everything what happened and I will do anything to get my money back and all the lost work, lost time, negligence, damage and I going to sue all the staff including the managers for the broke LCD cover. If CompUSA is not authorized to repair Toshiba laptops in the warranty time the local authorities will place a penalty about $10,000 to CompUSA because it’s illegal to place any fraudulent or fake announcement on any store, marketplace or business.

PEOPLE, DO NOT BUY ANY TOSHIBA AND NEVER IN COMPUSA!!! THIS COULD BE YOUR WORST NIGHTMARE!!!!

Service number of this case is CompUSA is 0505 1-116844004
post #2 of 24
Ouch, that is some major issue!
post #3 of 24
that is really a touch break, i honestly think that the beef is more with compusa than toshiba. i do recognise that the a70/a75 series were not very good, and did have the problems which you mentioned of the static issues. Compusa had your laptop for weeks on end,and it is very likely that the additional faults were the responsibility of compusa for how they treated your lappy while they had it. it is sad that you ended up getting a lemonthat missed the usual checks, however i do belive that the vast majorit yof your problems center around compusa lying and generally screwing around with you. Good luck in going after compusa, but leave the blame where it belongs not with toshiba but square on the shoulders of compusa.
post #4 of 24
Thread Starter 
Yes, CompUSA is the major problem. Actually I was talking with the manager and he told my that the HD of my laptop was replaced but he didn't know where is the motherboard and the LCD cover of my laptop. He said that everytime that he made the order of the LCD cover Toshiba cancel it without no reason. He told me also that the order of the LCD cover is not handle by the warranty process, obviously they broke it, they have to pay it. Weird no? IF this story is true Toshiba is part of the problem too or CompUSA is playing with me.
post #5 of 24
my bet from working in the retail world before is that they are playing you there man...
post #6 of 24
I'm glad your suing Compusa... bought a toshiba 5205-s703 from them with extended warranty and was without it for a month with no way of tracing it ( they kept changing SO numbers ) ...

Anyways, Good luck!
post #7 of 24
Thread Starter 

News Of Compusa Of Hell

DAMN! I'm sorry for you wazzup. They are (compusa) a lot of inepts.
I went ot CompUSA yesterday and after making a show in the store and yelling a lot one of the managers said to me that my laptop would be fixed it 35 minutes. Hahaha I waited to see the machine be repaired in 35 minutes because the Service Manager (that he wasn't there) told that the parts were not there and thy will take a long time to arrive, and he told me that the day before hehehe. SO, in 35 minutes my laptop was "REPAIRED". The cover was changed, the motherboard and teh hard drive. I think thay have to dismount on laptop to put the parts in my laptop or magic.

Well the funny issue is... the laptop was doing the same problem. When you touch the underneath area it's freeze. So I call all the manager, made a show again and I left the laptop there because they dont want to replace my laptop or return my money.

If you want to see the ineptitude of a customer service the best example is CompUSA check this... today i called the tech manager and he told me that my laptop wasn't repaired and the parts didn't arrive yet.

He have no idea of was is happening in the store. What kind of loser is thi manager? When I told him what happened yesterday I was in shock and didn't know what to say. He just hung up the phone.
post #8 of 24
Thread Starter 
I will send letters to local newspapers, radio and tv shows of Puerto Rico about this. Everyone here really have to know what CompUSA really is. I'm not the only one here.

NEVER BUY ANYTHING FROM COMPUSA NEVER!
post #9 of 24

BestBuy is not any Better



I got my Sony GXV series from bestbuy with 2 Years Services agreement.
They said that if the laptop need 3 repair, you will get a new one
The laptop's LCD just went blank because of the dead backlight, 1st service.
I found out that they have to ship the laptop out for 3+ weeks, and YOU ARE LEAVE WITHOUT A MACHINE.
After 5 months later, backlight went dead again. another 3 weeks.
When I got back the laptop.. all the screw are missing.. keyboard is poping out and benzel are all WITHOUT Screws.
I went back to Bestbuy and demand for a replacement or a new one they promised on the contract. Bestbuy said "After 3 times, means the 4th time they will replace it if it is still broken).

After 3rd times, When I trying to install OS, the Machine keeps freezing up.
So I return to Bestbuy and ask for a replacement by the contract.
Bestbuy said: We have to ship it back to the service center and they will decide if that is the lemon......WHAT HAPPEN TO THE CONTRACT!!!
IT says: if the laptop need 4th service, they will replace it. It did not say that they will repair it FIRST..
What a Crook company.....

Compusa, Bestbuy.. They are all the same....
post #10 of 24
Thread Starter 

A light in the dark...

Well guys... after all this mess with compusa today they fixed my laptop. One of the techs told me all the "truth" about my laptop and he really fixed it. He told me that my laptop had a "known issue" of Toshiba. He said that Toshiba made differents motherboards with differents cases. Those cases have differents ground lines routed inside and the motherboard have to match those ground lines inside of the case. For some reason Toshiba place wrong motherboards in wrong cases making the case a short in the motherboard when is pressed. Toshiba noticed this issue after the laptops were on stores.

I don't know if this story is truth but my laptop it's working fine now. He, Carlos Gallardo, personally changed the motherboard, all the exterior case including the LCD cover that they (compusa) broke and the hard disk. The motherboard was redesigned by Toshiba to correct all the issues and with a new version of the BIOS. Thanks to Carlos gestion I have my laptop again and a functional one, well I hope hehehe. I'l bet that the Service Manager doesn't have a clue about this.

For now I will hold any legal actions againt CompUSA while my laptop works fine. Well, I hope that this experience of horror will be the last with CompUSA and my laptop works nicelly for a long long long time now.
post #11 of 24
Well, I can say that I have been fortunate with the computers I bought at compusa - so far. I just bought a new toshiba - my third - there last month. So far, so good. But with my first computer I learned the service plans are a major WOTAM (waste of time and money). If u are used to going everywhere with your computer, what makes these people thing u will be happy with nothing at all for 3 weeks?!!!!

I had a hard drive failure on my first toshiba; I took it in to an authorized service dealer - luckily before the warranty was up ) - and got it fixed the same day.

But this was in Miami, though. I don't know how well they train managers at CompUSA . . .

kaysee
post #12 of 24
I still have time to get my money back for the 2 year extended service warranty. I wasn't sure when I bought it whether it was worth it. "Insurances" are all fraudulent to me. I'm in the midst of trying to get an air conditioner repaired under a home warranty and they are all corrupt.

I guess I just answered my own question. What is the next best option to protect myself in case something happens to my M45?
post #13 of 24
probably a rider on your home insurance policy... but since you seem to hate warranties and insurance, i guess not abusing it and definately not dropping it. buy a good laptop case and rarely take it outside of the house.
post #14 of 24

Thanks phaserkb

I very sorry for your experience, but I hope we all learn a good lesson from that. Thanks for sharing with us. I never buy anything at compusa, but I bought 2 desktop computers at Bestbuy, never have no problem because I DO NOT buy the service plan or extended warrenty. That is only for them to make more money and it is Very big hassle. Any friend I know who take computer there to be fix, waits very long time to get it back. They always got to order parts from far away, always take way too long. I need my computer every day, I can no wait. If it break, I fix myself. I make total backup every week to external hard drive. My Computers have no problems. I will buy my first laptop next year, doing research now, I like the Fujitsu N6210 best so far, still looking, will probably buy it thru the mail order.
Thanks again,
AL
post #15 of 24
well this revives a very old thread.... thank you.
post #16 of 24
I work at bestbuy, and as far as the 3 times service issue is concerned, it is true. Under your warranty (PSP). Performance Service Plan as it is called, bestbuy will give you store credit towards a "new" laptop once parts have been replaced/repaired on your existing unit. It does not apply towards software repairs or work done in the store. It has to be sent out 3 times specifically for hardware problems and those three times, parts HAVE to be replaced. Now, as a service technician, I am in charge of honoring those warranties, and you have to understand that things are out of our control once they leave our store. The service center honors all lemon policies and warranty exchanges. We are basically the middle person. Unfortunately, for most of the bestbuy locations, the service centers are out of state and it is very difficult for us to get answers. I do symphatize with you but, please understand that what the technician/manager told you was correct from what you say.


post #17 of 24
I have done allot of work w. Comp USA. Seams to me that they are a good company. But in general even good companies sometimes get bad employees.
post #18 of 24
wow another necro-post
post #19 of 24

Damn elcid79, just think if you only waited 52 days it would have been a year since nobody responded to this thread. But no.... you had to jump the gun and post early!!! You ruined it for all of us!


Note to noobs: Don't revive threads that have had no posts for over 60 days unless you actually have something to add to it like a solution to a problem.
post #20 of 24
Haha, I didnt even look @ the date. I assumed the forum had more action than that...
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Lenovo Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Lenovo Notebook Forums › Lenovo Notebooks › Toshiba-CompUSA Fatal Combination!!!