NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › Laptop to replace my desktop
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Laptop to replace my desktop

post #1 of 12
Thread Starter 
My current desktop is a Dell 4600, 2.6 GHz, 800 FSB w/ HT, GPU is a Nvidia 5200MX w/ 128 mb RAM (i *think*.. it might be 64mb).

I'd like a laptop to replace it, and have looked at many of the suggested models, and have mulled them over for the past few weeks. Although I'd love to have the advanced hardward in the XPS2 by Dell, screen quality is important to me; do they really sparkly bad? I looked at the Sager 9860, but it's just too ugly, as is their 7xxx model (forgot the exact number).

I love the way the Acer Ferrari looks, but is an ATI 9700 128 RAM going to be sufficient to do moderate gaming. I recently really got into Everquest II, and on my machine, many areas are OK, but the cities really clunk along. Thankfully, no crashing though.

The Asus 71V is OK re: looks, not the greatest. Also, I question if the Nvidia 6600go is good enough? I love the Asus V6V, but this uses the ATI x600... how does this fair to the 9700 or the 6600?

Cost is no object, up to $3000. 15" is probably preferable to 17", but I'm fine with 17". Centrino probably preferred, because most of the notebooks look better and are thinner. The P4 and AMD 64s are mostly clunky, the Ferrari being an exception. Obviously, looks are imporant, as is the screen. Some type of warranty is also... this is one reason I'm ruling out ibuypower.com; they won't warranty over 1 year (hate that).

Finally, I can probably wait a bit, if something is coming around the corner, but I don't want to wait more than 6-8 weeks. Is there a new Ferrari coming out soon that I should wait for? or, an upcoming offering from Asus that will offer better GPUs? I see that only a few of the notebooks offer the 915 chip by Intel, I'm thinking that this chipset is an important improvement?

thanks for your thoughts.
post #2 of 12
Dell Inspiron 6000 is quite good - Thats why im getting it!

P.S - why do you think you've got 64MB of RAM insted of 128MB?
post #3 of 12
Start -> Run -> type "dxdiag" and hit Enter -> Click on "Display"

It will tell you your video RAM under Approx. Total Memory.

As far as what to get... compared to your current graphics card/setup, any of the notebooks with an x600/9700 or above will blow it away and handle EQII nicely. The XPS or any system with the 6800 or x800 will demolish that game - highest settings across the board and no video lag. The x700 or 6600 will really good and you may only get lag in really intense battles. The 9700 or x600 will be better than what you have but not amazing.

Have you looked at the Acer Travelmate 8104? It could stand an HDD upgrade, but is well within your price range and has a nicely clocked x700 in it and a fast P-M, plus 1GB of RAM standard and its a little sleeker than the ASUS (and better video performance as well).
post #4 of 12
The best thing that you can do is to wait a bit for the new video cores of both NV and ATI to come out, which should be there in less than two months. If you want a top level gaming machine, then everything available out there right now will be long obsolete in about 6 months. You probably could get something like 7600Go or a similar cards in about 3 month, if you can wait that long. And there are talks of putting dual GPUs into a laptop, and let's see where NV goes with that idea.
post #5 of 12
Thread Starter 
Thanks for the input. Yes, it's 128MB ram, but I have a feeling the 5200MX card ain't so great. Yes, I could wait for a bit, but not 3 months. I'll take a look at the Travelmate 8104. I will probably end up waiting a bit, as it may be worth it to just see what happens in the next 4-6 weeks. I'm assuming Acer service is comprable to Dell, and other large companies?
post #6 of 12
Thread Starter 
So, that Acer 8104 actually fits the bill nicely. One thing, I think there is a typo here at newegg.com:

http://www2.newegg.com/Product/Produ...82E16834115178

It says the video RAM is shared? that must be wrong. The other listing (with slower CPU speed) says the video RAM is dedicated.

Anyway, I can also get a warranty through Acer here as well for an additional $200 or so (3 years). If there isn't something coming soon, and the X700 is going to suit me for a while, I think I'm goign to jump on it.
post #7 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by sdaigneault
So, that Acer 8104 actually fits the bill nicely. One thing, I think there is a typo here at newegg.com:

http://www2.newegg.com/Product/Produ...82E16834115178

It says the video RAM is shared? that must be wrong. The other listing (with slower CPU speed) says the video RAM is dedicated.

Anyway, I can also get a warranty through Acer here as well for an additional $200 or so (3 years). If there isn't something coming soon, and the X700 is going to suit me for a while, I think I'm goign to jump on it.
Yes, a nice laptop. It supposedly runs a little hot, but nothing to burn a hole in your pants. I imagine that is a typo on Newegg... I don't think they make a shared x700
post #8 of 12
Thread Starter 
heat's not an issue for me. of course i've now read about problems some have had with high pitched buzzing, and poor service from acer. i'm sure no one is perfect, but this confirms what i've always thought of acer: poorer quality laptop vs. ibm, others, but i may be wrong. in any case, i will sleep on it some.
post #9 of 12
i think it is safe to say acer = poor quality than IBM.. b/c IBM makes like the sturdiest laptops.. acer is good.. but IBM is IBM
post #10 of 12
Quote:
Originally Posted by 1CenT
i think it is safe to say acer = poorer quality than IBM.. b/c IBM makes like the sturdiest laptops.. acer is good.. but IBM is IBM
Amen, I think the majority on this forum would agree with that statement. But Acer is still quite good in its own right, maybe in the league of Asus and the like.
post #11 of 12
Acer is a mixed bag. If you go with the high end stuff like the Travelmate 8000+ series you should be safe. It's the lower end stuff that has quality issues.

Its sort of like at IBM - they are all good, but it is the T series in particular that are rock solid. The rest are still better than most, but do not compare to the T series.
post #12 of 12
Quote:
Its sort of like at IBM - they are all good, but it is the T series in particular that are rock solid. The rest are still better than most, but do not compare to the T series.
very true indeed. i swear by my IBM T series lappy
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Notebook Forums - General
NotebookForums.com › Forums › General Notebook Discussions › Notebook Forums - General › Laptop to replace my desktop