NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Forums › Asus Notebooks › V6V - W3V - You can only keep ONE! WHICH ONE WOULD YOU KEEP?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

V6V - W3V - You can only keep ONE! WHICH ONE WOULD YOU KEEP? - Page 2

Poll Results: You own the Asus V6V & W3V. But you can only keep ONE! Which one would you choose?

 
  • 44% (31)
    V6V
  • 55% (38)
    W3V
69 Total Votes  
post #21 of 28
Thread Starter 
RobotChicken I got it (a little late but I'm at work thats why). You are saying to change the processors between the two machines.

Do u think it is a thing I can do on my own? How risky could that be? Already thought of that but then bye bye guarantee... but on Asus is pretty reliable components.

Wont the battery life be reduced on the other hand with a 2.00 Ghz processor?
post #22 of 28
Thread Starter 
Here its the opposite with the RAM. V6V 533Mhz, W3V 400Mhz, but I checked and they are both 400Mhz!!! I'll call ASUS later today...
post #23 of 28
Thread Starter 
Quote:
I voted for the W3V due to the fact that they're basically the same machine, with the exception of a glossy widescreen and lighter chassis... and weight is a major concern, at least in my mind.
AuroraS
I assure you the weight of the two machines is exactly the same! 2.5-2.6 kilos
post #24 of 28
they weigh the same?

according to the specs
w3v: 4.8lbs
v6v: 5.5lbs

This is false?
post #25 of 28
jojo123, you are correct.
post #26 of 28
I think the processor should be pretty easy to switch, but I've never even opened the CPU compartment on any laptop before. I wouldnt think it should make much difference as far as battery life.

As for the weight a couple people at notebookreview weighed the w3v at 5.6 lbs with the 8-cell battery and the DVD burner. I think the weight ASUS says is with a 4-cell battery and travelers drawer.
post #27 of 28
Wouldn't the 2ghz processor make the W3v, with its smaller chassis, much hotter and noisier vis-a-vis fans? I already hear thigns about the W3v being quite hot on the palm rests, would a 2 gig processor + extra ram make it much hotter?
post #28 of 28
Thread Starter 
Hello to everyone
Been a long time I havent visited notebookforums mostly because I made my choice and I'm very happy with it. I kept the W3V. But as some suggested I made some modifications.

W3V model had some features I wanted and was impossible to have with the V6V:

8x DVD-R speed
S-Video out
Longer battery life
(~30 min more than the V6V)

I took from the V6V:

the HD (80BG @5400rpm)
the processor (replaced the 1.73 one with the V6V 2.00)
one of the 512 RAM that was on the V6V


and I put them on the W3V.

Result: Everything works fine!

The processor was pretty easy to change though you have to be very careful
The machine I have now is very compact, has everything I could want on a light-weight laptop. Really happy with it.

For the moment I dont have any heat problems on the palmrest. On the downside it gets pretty warm but not what I would call hot or somehow disturbing.

I went with some overall benchamrks and compared with other laptops on the net and I was very satisfied. e.g 1min37secs to calculate 2M digits Pi with "Super Pi", 366 pts with Performance Test, 12159 for 3DMark 2001. As for games NFSU2, F1 2002 and Virtual Pool (Its the games I play most) they work flawlessly. For more recent or demanding games I guess most would turn fine but for this you'll have to try them.

Cons:

The fan turns on more often than before and there is a little more noise but still nothing bothering. I hope a future bios update will improve this as this model comes with such a processor as an option.

As many have noticed the sound in the W3V is not very good, not the quality but the volume. It doesnt have any distortion but it doesnt get as loud as I'like. The last update I found on the Asus site improved this but dont expect any miracles. At this point the V6V had an advantage as it was really loud for a laptop even if there was no bass at all. But I guess this goes for all laptops unless they have an integrated subwoofer like the Asus W1.

I guess some people are wondering "what about the guarantee?"
Well normally, no more guarantee I guess unless I have the luck Asus wouldn't mind in case I needed Asus support. From my experience Asus notebooks have top quality so I'm not really worried about it. But I'm sure some of you are sceptical and would consider this crazy and without any important reason to do it. At the beginning I was hesitating but for me its a matter of feeling like with most things in life (goes the same for my guitars). I ended feeling better with the
W3V in my hands with its final custom configuration than the V6V.

Honestly if I needed 2 laptops and had more money for the rest of my projects I would have kept both. From what I've seen, Asus indeed has THE best design IMHO. I also believe the same about quality and features for the purposes I wanted it.

Thanx to those who gave their opinion, suggestions or voted at the poll.
I'd be glad to answer to your questions if u have any.

Peace
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Asus Notebooks
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Forums › Asus Notebooks › V6V - W3V - You can only keep ONE! WHICH ONE WOULD YOU KEEP?