NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Notebook Forums › Asus Notebook Reviews › Review: GamingTechy's - Z71v disappointment
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:

Review: GamingTechy's - Z71v disappointment

post #1 of 80
Thread Starter 
I am new here and would like to share my experience with my new Z71v and get any feedback you can offer, thanks!

I received my book two days a go, I have the Z71v with 1GB DDR2 533 Corsair, 80gb Spinpoint samsung drive, 1.86 cpu.

Total price 1425

The first time I turned the unit on I wanted to go into the bios and make sure ti saw everything correctly, I hit F2 to go in bios screen pops up....then it instantly freezes, the blue bar on the top of the screen stops flashing by, everything was frozen. As a computer tech I know its a very bad thing when a computer freezes before it even boots into windows, but I had hoped it was the fact I was running of battery and plugged it in. No good same thing 5 times in a row. Then I gave up and continued to load windows...hoping it was a bad bios flash or something (wishful thinking) got windows loaded without a problem and continued to load drivers and software. The computer hard froze again when I put in the driver CD. Now I'm rather annoyed and pissed off, but again more wishful thinking came into play and i thought maybe it just needed all the drivers loaded before it would run stably in windows. I got all the drivers loaded with out a problem and continued to load Office, and then 3dMark03, it scored 4300 with stock drivers and 4500 on the new asus drivers. Everything running more or less ok, although I expected a higher 3dmark score....and I could of sworn I saw a couple artifacts...but maybe it was just a glitch in 3dmark. I then loaded up UT04 and started to play. The first thing I noticed was with the res at the native res. (I forget what it is sorry) and all the graphics turned all the way down i was only getting 25fps, totally unplayable for a fast paced FPS game. Disgusted I turn the res down to 1024x768, and that got the fps up to 60....still disgusted and embarrassed at my friends little lan party, and my other friend next to me on his AMD 3500+ with a 9700 running UT04 with out a problem smirking his head off, I attempted to play, being the first time I lost a string of game ever against my friends at UT04 I was starting to get highly annoyed trying to figure out what was wrong or if it really was suppose to preform this poorly. Then the screen goes blank and the computer reboots, only the screen never came back on...I could just hear the computer booting and windows stupid chime. So i hit the button turned it off brought it back up screen came back on but was flickering real bad. I thought maybe it was the new Asus drivers so I loaded up the old ones and started up UT again. the FPS were still pathetic and I could hardly play, that is until the computer rebooted again and I couldn't play at all. Only this time the comp booted up with out video drivers installed, and it would not reinstall saying my card was not compatible, so the only thing that worked was forcing the driver then installing the software over it. Again, I tried a game, but this time Word of Warcraft, two hours later after installing and updating i opened the game up to 19-20 fps at high res with all graphics down. Now, pissed off i tried to exit the game, only before it could exit the comp rebooted again, This time retaining its video drivers though. after my friends got off the floor laughing I decided it was time go go home, I was trying to think what would cause theses problems and I came up with system memory, or video card. So i ran Memtest all night long, woke up to it still going with out recording a single error (please note this program keeps the cpu at 100% as well) So that seemed to rule out the CPU and system memory, so I'm guessing it must be the video card.

What do you guys think? would that cause the laptop to randomly freeze in the bios as well as windows?


On to my only other two gripes about the notebook.

First and foremost the screen! I know other reviewers have said that the "sparkles" are on all wsga+ screens and that you can only see it on all white backgrounds...but im sorry i have to call BS on that. It's more like a film over the entire screen and you can see it on almost any color, and even in games....and to me it really cuts down on the computing experience having to look through what looks like a bunch of huge pixels. I took it side by side next to my friends gateway laptop with the 3500+ (his screen is what made me want to get a wide screen laptop btw) his had no such "sparkles" I could tell at all, and the screen its self had quality that was simply amazing compared to mine, not to mention the gloss it has on it really gives it a nice shiny look.

2nd. Its ugly I think, the colors are dull and unimpressive, but it is very sturdy which to me is more important.

Thanks for reading guys, and let me know what you think is wrong.
post #2 of 80
Sounds like bad RAM...do some memory tests and see if your RAM is bad.
post #3 of 80
Anyone that says "sparkles" are on all wsxga+ screens have no idea what they are talking about.
post #4 of 80
The term sparkles are too losely used.
post #5 of 80
Thread Starter 
I said that I ran memory tests all night like with out an error.
post #6 of 80
Hmmm... where did you get it from? With your price compared to your specs, you got it a lot cheaper than any reseller that I know of is selling it for. Obviously something is seriously wrong with the hardware. I'm not a computer tech, so I won't embarrass myself by trying to guess what it is (I've done this in the past and learned my lesson ). Send it back to the reseller and have them fix it. That's what warrantees are for.
post #7 of 80
Thread Starter 
What i saw from resellers was they all offered the cpu and barebone laptop cheap then made up for it on everythign else, so i bought the laptop cpu and wireless card from gentechpc.com, it included the CDRW drive with free shipping. I then bought the ram and hard drive from newegg.com.
post #8 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Djembe_Rob
Hmmm... where did you get it from? With your price compared to your specs, you got it a lot cheaper than any reseller that I know of is selling it for.
I was thinking that too! that is a very low price for those specs and it should at least be $1600
post #9 of 80
Thread Starter 
that is why i went with this system, i shopped around for weeks so I could get it under 1500 dollars, does anyone have any input on my problems though?
post #10 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by GamingTechy
Total price 1425
This is your problem. The same system for the same specs normally costs up to $300 more.

There have been numerous reports on the sparkles of the Z71V, so it shouldn't come as a shock. And if it's so ugly, why did you even buy it in the first place? There have been plenty of photos lingering around too.

Get a Dell, if you want
post #11 of 80
The thing about the sparkles is that it is really impossible to know exactly what that means until you see the screen. This worries me as a possible buyer of a Z71v.
post #12 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by Blaker
The thing about the sparkles is that it is really impossible to know exactly what that means until you see the screen. This worries me as a possible buyer of a Z71v.
The June 2005 issue of Mobile Magazine got a clip review of the Asus Z71V. They gave it a 4/5. No mention of Sparkie. Just said, nice awesome screen!.

ahahha
post #13 of 80
on this site.. i cannot see sparkles even if i tried realli hard except on the lighter grey/white
there are sparkles on all lightish colours..
the screen is sparkles screen just that ppl don't find it annoying.. i think it is fine.. but i prefer non sparkles.. of course.. but then again i prefer the size/feel/specs of the z71v

i actually like the way it looks.. better than the sony's/hp's/dell's

when i went to class with my laptop.. a lot of ppl walked by looking at it.. maybe its the silver .. it really looks outstanding
post #14 of 80
that price is about right if you build from a barebone
the samsung harddrive is like $80 bucks cheaper than a seagate/hitachi
mine build out to be about 1600us including winXP home
post #15 of 80
Thread Starter 
the price is not the issue, my memory is corsair my hard drive is samsung, samsung may not be the best name in hard drives but even if it was a bad HDD it would not cause the issues mentioned, and corsair is a very respected memory seller. Building your system on your own is simply cheaper, laptop reseller aren't giving them a way free and even they cant get prices much better then newegg or zipzoomfly can offer. As for the non issue remarks about my personal opinion about the laptops screen and style, when people said sparkle it sounded to me like they meant a rainbow effect of swirling colors from a glossy finish, you really have no idea until you see it in person. As for the style...yes i saw photos and I can live with it...does not mean I'm doing back flips over it...so please do not bash me for my opinions on the screen and look.


now if anyone has any hard advice or tests they would ask of me to run I would be very grateful

latest update is now it only turns on about 1 out of every 20 trys, then restarts as soon as a graphical app is launched.
post #16 of 80
Quote:
Originally Posted by GamingTechy
the price is not the issue, my memory is corsair my hard drive is samsung, samsung may not be the best name in hard drives but even if it was a bad HDD it would not cause the issues mentioned, and corsair is a very respected memory seller. Building your system on your own is simply cheaper, laptop reseller aren't giving them a way free and even they cant get prices much better then newegg or zipzoomfly can offer. As for the non issue remarks about my personal opinion about the laptops screen and style, when people said sparkle it sounded to me like they meant a rainbow effect of swirling colors from a glossy finish, you really have no idea until you see it in person. As for the style...yes i saw photos and I can live with it...does not mean I'm doing back flips over it...so please do not bash me for my opinions on the screen and look.


now if anyone has any hard advice or tests they would ask of me to run I would be very grateful

latest update is now it only turns on about 1 out of every 20 trys, then restarts as soon as a graphical app is launched.
you might be better off asking sum1 who had experience building the z71v from barebone.. maybe carefully look at the manual again? maybe u missed some pins or wutever? i dunno..
post #17 of 80
Thread Starter 
looking at the manual i do do not see anywhere where it gets into the insides of the laptop.
post #18 of 80
Thread Starter 
even the though memory test checked out im more and more starting to suspect something iffy about it.....the symptoms just have RAM all over it.
post #19 of 80
Send it back, it's obviously faulty.
post #20 of 80
Thread Starter 
I would love to just start sending stuff back, but which group of parts are bad? the stuff purchased with the barebone or the memory from newegg?
New Posts  All Forums:Forum Nav:
  Return Home
  Back to Forum: Asus Notebook Reviews
NotebookForums.com › Forums › Notebook Manufacturers › Asus Notebook Forums › Asus Notebook Reviews › Review: GamingTechy's - Z71v disappointment